Safety · Grinzane Cavour, Cuneo, and Bollate
Cassation calls jeweller Mario Roggero's 2021 shooting of robbers a deliberate aggression
Italy's Court of Cassation has published the reasons for making final the 14-year, 9-month sentence of Mario Roggero, a Grinzane Cavour jeweller who killed two robbers in April 2021. The judges found he fired at the robbers after the raid was over and they were fleeing.
AI text based on reports by Open, Il Sole 24 ORE, ANSA.it and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The Cassation's first criminal section filed 34 pages of reasons for its 15 July ruling, making Roggero's 14-year, 9-month sentence final.
The court found Roggero chased the robbers out of his Grinzane Cavour shop and fired after the robbery was over, when the danger to his family had passed.
The court cited ballistic findings describing a first shot from about half a metre, then shots with an outstretched arm at two robbers bent over by the car.
Roggero told the press after the 28 April 2021 shooting that his move was the only way to stop the robbers, and the court relied on those statements.
- 2007Roggero receives a two-year sentence for insult and aggravated threat, later replaced by a fine
- 28 AprRobbery at his Grinzane Cavour shop; he fires, killing two robbers and wounding a third
- 15 JulCourt of Cassation ruling makes the 14-year, 9-month sentence final
- 17 NovCourt publishes 34 pages of reasons for the ruling
A final sentence and the court's reasoning
The Court of Cassation's first criminal section has published 34 pages of reasons for its ruling of 15 July, which rejected the defence appeal and made the sentence final. Mario Roggero, a 72-year-old jeweller from Grinzane Cavour in the province of Cuneo, was convicted of killing two robbers and wounding a third after a raid on his shop on 28 April 2021. The court accepted the Attorney General's request to reject the appeal and concluded that his action was a deliberate aggression.
“Roggero, with a voluntary and conscious choice, channelled his action into a deliberate aggression not justified by the need for defence.”
The judges also found no mere lapse in how Roggero judged the danger or the means of escape, which in their view made the act deliberate rather than a misreading of the situation.
Why self-defence was rejected
The court agreed with the earlier ruling that neither real nor believed self-defence applied. Roggero chased the robbers out of the shop and fired while the raid was already over and the men were trying to get away. The judges said the danger to his life and to his family's safety had ended by then, something he had clearly been able to perceive. The defence argued he feared for his wife, but the court rejected that account, noting that he had bumped into her and moved her aside as he left the shop to give chase. The appeal also raised the possibility that the robbers might turn back, which the court called purely hypothetical, since the stolen goods had already been seized.
Ballistic findings and his earlier statements
According to the court, ballistic and expert evidence pointed to an intent to kill. The first shot was fired from about half a metre, after which Roggero moved and, with his arm outstretched, fired at two robbers who were bent over as they got into the car. The court held that his statements to the press after the shooting were usable because he gave them spontaneously. In those interviews he said his move was the only way to stop the robbers and bring them to justice. The judges also noted that he had been robbed before without the attackers being properly punished, which had led him to doubt that the state could deliver justice to crime victims.
The court also rejected the defence objection to the use of a 2007 conviction. In that case Roggero received a two-year sentence for insult and aggravated threat, later replaced by a fine, after he went armed to the home of his daughter's ex-boyfriend. The court said this was consistent with a psychiatric assessment that pointed to impulsiveness in critical situations.
A letter from Bollate prison
Roggero has been held at Bollate prison near Milan for almost three months. A letter from him was due to be read on the evening of 17 November on Retequattro's Fuori dal Coro, hosted by Mario Giordano. In it he wrote:
“I have had occasion, by force of circumstance, to reflect on the events, and I am grasping entirely new and unthinkable aspects.”
He described entering prison at over 72, after more than half a century of work, as very devastating for him, both psychologically and above all physically. He thanked the millions of Italians who had supported him and said he would write again later.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- OpenMario Roggero, le motivazioni della Cassazione sul gioielliere che uccise due rapinatori: "Una deliberata aggressione per farsi giustizia da sé"
- Il Sole 24 ORERoggero agì con dolo, sparò ai rapinatori in fuga per farsi giustizia da sè
- ANSA.it++ Roggero condannato, giudici 'da lui deliberata aggressione' ++ - Notizie
- ANSA.itRoggero condannato, i giudici: 'Da parte sua una deliberata aggressione' - Notizie
- Mario Giordano
- Host of Retequattro's Fuori dal Coro, which was to read a letter from Roggero
- Places
- Grinzane Cavour, Cuneo, Milan
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar