Safety · Strasbourg and Ankara

European Court orders Turkey to free jailed lawmaker Can Atalay and pay €32,500

The European Court of Human Rights found on Tuesday, 17 November, that Turkey's detention of Can Atalay breached the European Convention on Human Rights four times. The judgment orders his immediate release, his return to parliament and €32,500 in moral damages.

AI text based on reports by Deutsche Welle, BBC, stern.de and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Strasbourg, Ankara · France, Turkey
How it came to this
  1. 16 AprAtalay lodges his application with the European Court of Human Rights
  2. 2024Parliamentary status revoked, a decision the Constitutional Court later overturned
  3. 17 NovEuropean Court publishes judgment ordering his release

The ruling

The European Court of Human Rights published its judgment on Tuesday, 17 November, finding that Turkey's detention of lawyer and elected lawmaker Can Atalay breached the European Convention on Human Rights in four respects. The court ordered his immediate release, his return to his seat in the Turkish parliament and the payment of €32,500 in moral damages (about $35,700). Judges held that his imprisonment after his election was unlawful and that its purpose was to silence him and undermine political pluralism. The provisions found breached were Article 5(1) on liberty and security, Article 5(4) on judicial review of detention, Article 3 of Protocol No. 1 on free elections, and Article 18 on restrictions used for an improper purpose. The judges also asked that the case be seen alongside the detention of political opponents, rights activists and journalists in Turkey. The majority decision drew one dissent: Saadet Yüksel, the judge sitting for Turkey, voted against three of the four violations and against the immediate release order, agreeing only on Article 5(4).

Background to the detention

Atalay, a lawyer who represented victims in social and political cases, was among the leading voices in the 2013 Gezi Park protests. In April 2022 he was sentenced, together with seven others, to 18 years in prison for aiding and abetting an attempted coup, a charge the government had described the protests as. He was held in Silivri prison, and in the parliamentary elections of 14 May 2023 he stood for the Workers' Party of Turkey (TIP) in Hatay and won a seat. Despite Constitutional Court rulings in his favour, he was not released, and his parliamentary status was revoked in 2024, a decision the Constitutional Court later overturned. He had lodged his application with the European Court on 16 April 2024.

Turkey has previously refused to comply with the court's decisions in the cases of Osman Kavala and Selahattin Demirtaş, according to Deutsche Welle. Stern reported that the court had asked Turkey in August to release Kavala and that Turkey had not done so. Amnesty International, cited by Stern, counted 5,500 people prosecuted after the Gezi protests.

Reactions in Ankara

Erkan Baş, leader of TIP, called on parliament speaker Numan Kurtulmuş and all political parties to act after the ruling. He said Atalay should be registered in the parliamentary roll and released, and that he should take the oath and do his job.

“Can Atalay must be registered in the parliamentary roll immediately, released, and made to take the oath and carry out his duties.”

Erkan Baş, leader of the Workers' Party of Turkey

Baş also said that because the Constitutional Court's rulings had not been applied, Atalay had been deprived of judicial protection for his liberty, and he put the vote on the other points at six to one. On Monday, 16 November, Petra Bayr, president of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, said Turkey was bound to implement the court's judgments, which she described as obligations rather than recommendations.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar