Government · Valencia

Zapatero asks court for access to seized jewels for a new appraisal by his own experts

Former prime minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero has named two Valencia experts to appraise jewels police seized from his office in May, and asked the judge to release the pieces to them.

AI text based on reports by EL PAÍS, La Razón, El Confidencial and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Ministerio de Cultura de la Nación, CC BY-SA 2.0 (Wikimedia Commons, cropped)
How it came to this
  1. May 2026Police seize jewels from Zapatero's office
  2. September 2026Judge acknowledges Zapatero's right to present his own appraisal
  3. 17 NovDefence names two experts and asks for access to the jewels

The defence's request

José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero has asked judge José Luis Calama of the Audiencia Nacional, who is handling the Plus Ultra case, to order that the jewels police seized from his office last May be handed to his lawyer, Víctor Moreno Catena, so they can be made available to his appraisers. The filing, reported on 17 November 2026, says the judge acknowledged in September that Zapatero had the right to present his own appraisal against the one drawn up by the experts the court chose. The defence has already named two experts for that purpose. The aim, according to the filing, is an alternative valuation that would bring down the figures produced by the court's appraisers.

Two appraisals, far apart

The judge already holds two valuations that put the seized pieces at around one million euros. The Ansorena appraisal valued them at 1.3 million euros, while Joyería Yanes put their value at one million euros.

Court-ordered appraisals of the seized jewelsEUR
Ansorena appraisal
1300000 EUR
Joyería Yanes appraisal
1000000 EUR

Data from the article text

A report seen by El Periódico puts the four lots analysed at 1,023,320 euros, and states that the set was not bought from a high-jewellery brand of recognised prestige. The judge has since asked the National Police's economic crime unit (UDEF) to try to identify the maker's mark on the jeweller's punch, which the appraisers could not match to any high-jewellery firm. The defence says the two appraisals show important discrepancies and that a new, independent report is necessary.

The new experts

The defence has chosen David Mellado Ortiz, a jeweller-gemologist, court expert and specialist in diamonds and coloured stones based in Valencia. The second expert is Rosa María Moreno García, a gemologist and appraiser who is a member of the Spanish Association of Jewellery Appraisers (AETA) and teaches at the University of Valencia's gemology studies. El Mundo reports that Mellado manages the family firm Mellado Joyeros, established in Valencia in 1966, and has more than 25 years of experience, while Moreno has more than 30 years of experience and works at the Gemior laboratories. The defence says that if its experts' conclusions differ on any point from those of the court's experts, they will examine the reasons for the gap and whether any material or technical judgement error occurred.

Access to the pieces and the Yanes report

The defence wants its experts to have physical contact with the pieces, to take photographs and measurements, and to carry out non-destructive tests, including X-ray fluorescence analysis of the metal. It asks that these operations take place in the presence of the unit that holds the jewels, with minutes recorded for each one. A second filing asks that Joyería Yanes provide the assay report prepared by the firm Saveco on the metal of the jewels, together with its photographic annex. El Periódico reports that the defence also wants the full report from the precious-metals testing laboratory cited in the Yanes appraisal. The articles do not say whether the judge has ruled on any of these requests.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Valencia
Valencia · Spain

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar