Conflicts · Brussels and Berlin

Pistorius apologizes for calling US criticism of Ukraine strikes 'stupid'

German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius said on Friday, 20 November, that he regretted his wording about a Pentagon official's criticism, while still backing Ukrainian long-range strikes inside Russia. The row started at a meeting of Ukraine's military backers in Brussels on Tuesday, 17 November.

AI text based on reports by Η Ναυτεμπορική, H Kαθημερινή, Mediafax.ro and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Photo: Olaf Kosinsky, CC BY-SA 3.0 de (Wikimedia Commons, cropped)
How it came to this
  1. 17 NovColby questions Ukrainian long-range strikes in Brussels; Pistorius calls the criticism 'quite a stupid thing' at a joint news conference
  2. 18 NovPistorius and Colby speak by phone on Wednesday evening
  3. 19 NovTrump meets Putin on Thursday, and three European officials tell POLITICO that Trump then called European allies about the cost of supporting Ukraine
  4. 20 NovPistorius tells POLITICO he apologized for his choice of words

The apology

German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius said on Friday, 20 November, that he had apologized for the words he used to describe a Pentagon official's criticism of Ukrainian strikes inside Russia. Speaking by phone to POLITICO, he admitted that he had reached for the wrong expression while answering a question in English, a language he does not speak natively, and said he had not considered the phrasing suitable even at the time. He had called the criticism 'quite a stupid thing' at a joint news conference held after the meeting in Brussels.

Pistorius said the regret concerned wording only, and he put it in plain terms:

“I apologized for my choice of words”

Boris Pistorius, german Defense Minister

He stressed that he has not changed his support for the strikes themselves, and he said the two governments simply see the matter differently.

Colby's objection and the phone call

The dispute began at Tuesday's, 17 November, meeting of the countries that give military support to Ukraine, a gathering known as the Ramstein Group. Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon's top policy official, questioned how effective Ukraine's long-range strikes on Russian oil infrastructure and other targets have been. In his view they had done little to bring the war to an end or to slow the Russian advance. He also argued that hitting infrastructure such as Wildberries warehouses, the Russian counterpart of Amazon, could harden attitudes among the Russian population.

Pistorius phoned Colby on Wednesday evening, 18 November, to discuss the episode. Both men described their position as a difference of views, with Pistorius saying the two sides agree to disagree.

Streeting and the wider gap

UK Defense Secretary Wes Streeting also defended Ukraine at Tuesday's meeting, though in a gentler register. During the conference he said:

“It's not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war.”

Wes Streeting, UK Defense Secretary

The exchange is one sign of a wider split. Berlin pays for the design and production of Ukraine's long-range weapons and remains Kyiv's largest financial backer. Separately, three European officials told POLITICO that after a meeting with Vladimir Putin on Thursday, 19 November, Donald Trump phoned European allies to complain about the money spent on Ukraine in a war that is killing many people.

What comes next

Pistorius insisted the disagreement will not damage bilateral defense cooperation, which Germany and the United States are trying to deepen through joint weapons production. He said the two countries are allies and partners, and that this does not oblige them to agree on everything. He also said his remarks should not strain relations between Berlin and Washington.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Brussels, Berlin · Belgium, Germany

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar