Conflicts · Beijing and Cologne

US officials say China's spies sought AI chips before the Nvidia scandal

US officials say China's Ministry of State Security worked with Alice Huang to spy on Nvidia's Jensen Huang, a claim Beijing rejects as 'pure fabrication'. The allegations have also drawn scrutiny of China's effort to obtain advanced AI chips.

AI text based on reports by RTVE.es, The Irish Times, RTE.ie and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Beijing, Cologne · China, Germany

The allegations

US officials say China's Ministry of State Security worked with Alice Huang, a Chinese businesswoman, to spy on Jensen Huang, the chief executive of Nvidia, a claim first reported by The New York Times. The Irish Times describes his relationship with her as an affair with a woman US authorities believe to have been a Chinese spy. It reports that two further affairs with employees were also reported and that he was then pushed out of the company. RTE refers to him as the former chief executive. According to RTVE, Alice Huang is suspected of diverting advanced microchips to Beijing and has been under US scrutiny since 2024. She has not responded to requests for comment from the New York Times.

Market fallout

RTVE, citing the Financial Times, says Nvidia lost about $1.5 trillion in value over a few weeks, which it calls the biggest jolt in the company's history. The Irish Times instead reports that Nvidia immediately lost half a trillion dollars of market value after the story broke. The two figures cover different spans of time and come from different outlets, so they should be read separately rather than as one total.

What the New York Times reports about China's chip campaign

Citing officials, the New York Times reports that China's espionage agency has run a secret campaign to help companies acquire advanced AI chips and to gather intelligence on the sector. According to several serving and former officials from governments in Asia, the United States and Europe, the Ministry of State Security has made acquiring advanced semiconductor chips a priority. Those chips include models the United States has barred Nvidia from exporting to China. The paper also cites an official text of a speech in which Xi Jinping told the Politburo in January that China must quickly resolve its 'chokehold' problems in future industries. China has rejected the espionage claims as 'pure fabrication'.

Expert assessments

Hans-Jacob Schindler, a specialist in international security, argues that Beijing risked exposure but that harming Nvidia already serves its strategy in the AI race, even if the operation fails. Luca Manns, who directs the Intelligence Services Research Centre at the University of Cologne, calls the case misleading because it feeds the James Bond cliche and honey traps, a tactic he says the MSS avoids because of its high operational risk. Nicholas Eftimiades, a former official of the US Defense Intelligence Agency and a professor at Penn State, sees a fairly standard script in which agents get close to a key target but fail in execution because their tradecraft is careless.

The wider pattern

RTE notes that accusations of economic espionage against China form a long line of cases, including honey traps, hacking, social engineering, agents placed in cutting-edge companies, and academic or business partnerships. Under Chinese rules, most American or European firms that set up in China must form a joint venture with a local company and share information and technology, a practice the article links to China's rise in the motor industry. Germany has previously claimed it loses tens of billions of euros and tens of thousands of jobs a year to economic espionage, with China as the main culprit. The EU has designated Huawei and ZTE as high-risk suppliers, and the article notes efforts to ban their devices outright in Europe.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar