Safety · Midleton, Sligo, and Carlow
Northern Ireland witnesses attend court but often never testify, inspectors find
Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland puts police court attendance in 2024-25 at almost 18,500 average working days, or £4m, and found many officers were not required to testify.
AI text based on reports by Irish Examiner, Irish Independent and BBC. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
CJI says police attendance at court in 2024-25 equated to almost 18,500 average working days, or £4m, and many officers were not required to testify.
Of 30 prosecution cases CJI reviewed, 34% of hearings went ahead as scheduled, with plea changes and lawyer availability among the factors.
CJI urges the PSNI and the Public Prosecution Service to notify officers when they are no longer required in court, to be done within six months.
Judge Colm Roberts told Midleton District Court on Thursday, 19 November 2026, that Joshua Allen, 26, must decide whether to plead guilty or request a book of evidence.
Attendance at court in Northern Ireland
A review by Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland (CJI) found that large numbers of witnesses summoned to court are never called to give evidence. Police officers, some taken away from front-line duty, are among those affected. The inspectorate linked part of the problem to last-minute guilty pleas by defendants. Police attendance at court in 2024-25 added up to almost 18,500 average working days, or £4m, yet in many cases officers were not needed in the witness box. CJI said the true scale of this inefficiency is hard to estimate because data collection is limited.
What the review measured
CJI examined 30 prosecution cases and found that only 34% of hearings went ahead as scheduled. Changes to pleas and the availability of lawyers were among the reasons. The inspectorate also surveyed witnesses. 60% of police officers and forensic scientists said they had testified rarely, and 55% of members of the public said they had not had to take the stand.
- Prosecution hearings going ahead as scheduled (30 cases reviewed)
- 34 %
- Police and forensic scientists saying they testified rarely
- 60 %
- Members of the public who did not have to testify
- 55 %
Data from the article text
Recommendations and police response
The report urges the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) to get a firmer handle on officer attendance at court and to work out what that costs in resources. It also calls on the PSNI and the Public Prosecution Service to build a system that tells officers when they are no longer needed, with that work to be done within six months. Acting chief inspector James Corrigan went further, saying digital methods of summoning witnesses, already used elsewhere in the UK, should be considered.
“This move to increased use of technology is long overdue.”
The PSNI said it was considering the findings. Assistant Chief Constable Anthony McNally said that late-cancelled attendances can affect how officers are deployed to front-line work.
Repeated adjournments in a Cork case
On Thursday, 19 November 2026, Judge Colm Roberts told Midleton District Court that it was decision time for Joshua Allen, 26, the eldest son of chef Rachel Allen. Allen faces nine charges, including allegedly driving a van at a garda and assaulting two gardaí, all dated to 27 October 2025 and alleged to have happened in Shanagarry, East Cork. He was due to enter a signed guilty plea or request a book of evidence that day, but the decision had already been put off in September and October. The case has been directed for trial on indictment in the circuit court. Defence solicitor Don Ryan asked for two more weeks, saying he was in ongoing contact with the Director of Public Prosecution's office, which had requested the delay. Roberts said he was hearing the same request at several sittings and wanted to be part of the decision. He put it plainly to the court.
“You have to make a decision.”
Driving cases in Sligo, Carlow and Wexford
At Sligo District Court, a 31-year-old driver was fined €250 after a collision at Knockmuldowney, Ballisodare, in July 2024. The charge was reduced from dangerous to careless driving because the State consented and had no evidence of speed. Another Sligo case involved a 23-year-old seminary student fined €250 for driving without insurance after a collision on 26 May. His policy had lapsed during a pilgrimage in France, and he took out new cover the next day, so he was not disqualified. In Carlow, a 53-year-old taxi driver who was already serving a two-year ban pleaded guilty to driving without a licence and without insurance, after failing to stop for gardaí on 3 November 2025. Judge Geraldine Carthy imposed a €350 fine payable within 90 days and a four-year disqualification. Carthy addressed the defence's plea for leniency directly.
“You are asking me not to disqualify him. You should be asking me not to jail him.”
At Wexford District Court, a 50-year-old Waterford man was banned from driving for two years after a dangerous driving conviction over a crash on the N11 on 24 May 2024. The driver of the car he struck suffered a broken arm and shoulder injuries, and one of her passengers a fractured sternum. His solicitor said he accepted responsibility and blamed momentary glare from the sun, while an independent witness described his van as all over the road.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Irish Examiner'It's decision time,' says judge after third adjournment of Joshua Allen garda assault case
- Irish IndependentDriver (31) fined after causing collision at accident blackspot in Sligo
- Irish ExaminerJudge tells disqualified Carlow taxi driver he should be asking not to go to jail
- Irish IndependentYoung man studying to become a priest fined for not having insurance after collision in Sligo
- James Corrigan
- Acting chief inspector at Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland who presented the report
- Joshua Allen
- 26-year-old facing nine charges at Midleton District Court, eldest son of chef Rachel Allen
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar