Government · Lisbon, Funchal, and Porto Santo
Forensic report finds NRP Mondego could not have shadowed Russian ship in 2023
A forensic study requested by a Lisbon court finds the NRP Mondego, sailing at 7 knots, would have needed about 2 hours and 10 minutes just to pass Ponta de São Lourenço in Madeira. Thirteen sailors are accused of insubordination for refusing the mission.
AI text based on reports by PÚBLICO, Notícias ao Minuto and Correio da Manha. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
A study by the Escola Superior Náutica Infante D. Henrique concludes the NRP Mondego, at 7 knots, could not have reached an interception point with a 15-knot Russian vessel near Madeira in March 2023.
Prosecutors accuse 13 military personnel of insubordination for refusing the mission, and the case remains in its pre-trial investigation phase.
Three navy personnel were acquitted on 21 October of violating state secrecy, and prosecutors appealed, as the Public Prosecutor's Office confirmed to Lusa on 17 November.
- 21 OctLisbon court acquits three navy personnel of violating state secrecy
- 6 NovDate of the forensic report on the interception calculations
- 17 NovProsecutors' appeal of the state-secrecy acquittal is confirmed to Lusa
Forensic findings
A forensic study requested by the instruction court in Lisbon concludes that the NRP Mondego could not have reached an interception point with a Russian vessel in March 2023 near the Madeira archipelago. The analysis was carried out by the Escola Superior Náutica Infante D. Henrique and is dated 6 November, according to a document Lusa accessed and Correio da Manhã reported. The experts calculated that the Portuguese ship, at seven knots (about 13 km/h), would have taken around 2 hours and 10 minutes to pass Ponta de São Lourenço. The Russian ship was moving at 15 knots, roughly 28 km/h, and the institute's experts concluded that the escort could not have happened, even if the Mondego had sailed from Funchal, where it was moored.
- NRP Mondego
- 7 knots
- Russian vessel
- 15 knots
Data from the article text
In the institute's own words, the conclusion is stated in direct terms.
“The escort would have been impossible.”
The insubordination case
Thirteen military personnel are accused of insubordination for refusing a mission to shadow the Russian vessel, which was north of Porto Santo. Prosecutors argued in the accusation that the Mondego was able to put to sea, although some conditions were degraded, including cracks in the deck, an inoperative engine and a fault in the engine's cooling pump. According to the prosecution, if the mission proved impossible the commander could have decided to return to port. The case is still in the pre-trial investigation phase.
Earlier assessments and the Navy's position
A technical study of the vessel's condition, cited by Correio da Manhã, found that on 11 March 2023 the ship did not meet the safety conditions needed to go to sea. In May 2026 the company Navaltk assessed the ship and listed deficiencies it said seriously compromised safety and operability. Those findings included an inoperative port engine, both engines running beyond their maintenance hour limits, flooding in lower compartments, an electrical system without a safety margin and firefighting pumps working outside maintenance parameters. After the refusal, the Navy, under the command of Admiral Gouveia e Melo, opened disciplinary proceedings against the sailors. The then chief of naval staff publicly rebuked the sailors and said the Navy does not send ships to sea when it considers they pose a risk to their crews.
Separate state-secrecy case
Three navy personnel from the Mondego face a separate case for allegedly violating state secrecy by sending information about the ship's condition to sergeant and enlisted men's associations. A Lisbon court acquitted them on 21 October, finding it had not been proven that the aim was to make the ship's technical limits public or that the interests and security of the state were put at risk. On Tuesday, 17 November, the Public Prosecutor's Office confirmed to Lusa that prosecutors had appealed that ruling.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- PÚBLICOForensic study concluded that it would be impossible for the ship Mondego to shadow a Russian ship in 2023Perícia concluiu que seria impossível navio <em>Mondego</em> acompanhar navio russo em 2023 · original in Portuguese
- Notícias ao MinutoForensic study reveals that NRP Mondego could not shadow a Russian ship in 2023Perícia revela que NRP Mondego não poderia acompanhar navio russo em 2023 · original in Portuguese
- Correio da ManhaNRP Mondego: Gouveia e Melo suffers another judicial defeatNRP Mondego: Gouveia e Melo sofre nova derrota judicial · original in Portuguese
- Gouveia e Melo
- Admiral under whose command the Navy opened disciplinary proceedings against the sailors who refused the mission
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar