Safety · Madison
Dane County prosecutor declines charges against Madison officer who fatally shot Black man
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said on Thursday, 19 November, that the officer who fatally shot a 38-year-old Black man in July acted reasonably. The victim's attorney, Ben Crump, said the videos showed excessive force and called the killing unjustifiable.
AI text based on reports by Tgcom24, AP NEWS, The Independent and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said on Thursday, 19 November, that the officer who shot a 38-year-old Black man on 22 July acted reasonably and would not face criminal liability.
Attorney Ben Crump, representing the family, said the videos show the man tackled, tased and kicked before being shot, and that the medical examiner said he would have survived without the head shot.
A few dozen people gathered at the site on Thursday, and a candlelight vigil was held after dark. Madison police officers do not wear body cameras.
- 22 JulOfficer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson fatally shoots a 38-year-old Black man during a police arrest in Madison
- 19 NovDane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announces no criminal charges against the officer
No charges for the officer
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced on Thursday, 19 November, that no criminal charges will be filed against the Madison police officer who fatally shot a 38-year-old Black man on 22 July. Ozanne concluded that the officer's use of deadly force was reasonable because the man resisted officers, produced a knife and was not stopped by multiple Taser attempts. The Wisconsin Department of Justice, whose Division of Criminal Investigation conducted the probe as state law requires for officer-involved deaths, said shortly after the shooting that the knife injured the officer. Ozanne said he reviewed police reports, scene diagrams, surveillance video, squad car video and citizen video, and that the evidence was consistent. He also noted that no body-worn cameras were used in the incident, because Madison officers do not wear them.
How the shooting unfolded
Officers responded to reports that a man was looking into parked cars and possibly attempting a burglary, officials said at the time. Kiel Baitinger-Peterson, a white officer with more than a decade in law enforcement, was one of four officers who responded. The officers surrounded the man, who was on a bicycle, at a busy Madison intersection in the middle of the day. According to the Wisconsin Department of Justice, two officers tried to use a Taser on him without success, and he brandished a knife and injured the officer. The shooting was captured on video, and the footage circulated widely online and touched off days of tense protests.
Family and attorney respond
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who represents the victim's family, said nothing in the videos justified the shooting. He said the footage shows officers tackling, tasing and kicking the man before an officer shot him. Crump described the case as one of the worst excessive force cases he has worked on. He said the medical examiner told the family the man would have survived had the third shot, to the head, not been fired. Crump said the prosecutor showed the family video of the shooting on Thursday, and he repeated that the videos contained nothing to justify the force used.
“The video is the objective unbiased witness here.”
The victim's brother told reporters the prosecutor had mistreated the family, and the family described itself as devastated by the decision.
Legal reasoning and protests
Ozanne said his decision was a correct interpretation of the law and that the law applies equally to members of law enforcement and to those who are not. He put his reasoning this way.
“A person does not have to like and/or agree with the law, however I am sworn to apply the law to the facts at hand.”
City leaders braced for more protests in the hours after the decision. A few dozen people gathered at the site by late afternoon, where bouquets of flowers marked the busy intersection, and a candlelight vigil was held after dark. Demonstrators had blocked traffic for days after the July shooting, when the footage first spread online.
Timeline of the case
The case ran from the shooting on 22 July to the prosecutor's decision on Thursday, 19 November.
Crump's statement called the killing unjustifiable, unreasonable, unnecessary and unconstitutional, while the prosecutor's office stated that the review was limited to whether criminal charges could be merited.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Tgcom24USA, street shooting: police open fire and kill a manUsa, sparatoria in strada: la polizia apre il fuoco e uccide un uomo · original in Italian
- AP NEWSProsecutor declines to charge a Madison, Wisconsin, police officer who fatally shot a Black man
- The IndependentCop who fatally shot Black man on bike in Madison won't be charged, prosecutor says
- The New York Timesmadison-shooting-corey-ruiz-district-attorney-statement
- Ben Crump
- Civil rights attorney representing the victim's family
- Places
- Madison
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar