Housing · Karlsruhe and Hamburg
Federal Constitutional Court upholds landlords' early termination of cable TV contracts
Germany's Federal Constitutional Court dismissed complaints from three cable network operators, ruling that landlords' special termination right for old bulk TV contracts did not violate the Basic Law. The judgment was announced in Karlsruhe on Monday, 16 November 2026.
AI text based on reports by Handelsblatt, Süddeutsche Zeitung, N-tv and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The First Senate dismissed complaints by Willytel from Hamburg, Rehnig Breitbandnetze & Kabelfernsehen GmbH and Ziegelmeier GmbH from Bavaria on Monday, 16 November 2026, under case 1 BvR 1803/22.
The special termination right let landlords end contracts concluded before December 2021 from July 2024, with no notice period unless agreed otherwise and no damages owed, after a transition period ending 30 June 2024.
Stephan Harbarth said the overall burden on the operators was considerable but that the legislature had not exceeded its constitutional room for shaping policy, pointing to the multi-year transition period.
- December 2021Telecommunications law reform adopted, abolishing the utility-cost privilege
- 1 JulSpecial termination right takes effect after the transition period ends
- 16 NovFederal Constitutional Court dismisses three cable operators' complaints
What the court decided
On Monday, 16 November 2026, the Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe dismissed constitutional complaints from three cable network operators against a special termination right that let landlords end old bulk TV contracts. The First Senate found that the provision did not breach the Basic Law, rejecting claims that the companies' property and occupational freedoms had been violated. The complainants are Willytel, a regional operator from Hamburg, and the Bavarian firms Rehnig Breitbandnetze & Kabelfernsehen GmbH and Ziegelmeier GmbH, filed under case number 1 BvR 1803/22. They argued that they alone had borne all the costs of abolishing the utility-cost privilege, and that this had cut their revenue. Harbarth conceded that the overall burden on the operators was considerable, but concluded:
“the legislature has not yet exceeded the constitutional limits of its scope for shaping policy”
Background: the end of the utility-cost privilege
Until the change, landlords could pass the cost of a shared cable connection in an apartment building on to tenants through service charges, and tenants had no say in the arrangement. The telecommunications law reform adopted in December 2021 abolished this utility-cost privilege, with a transition period that ran until 30 June 2024. Alongside it, lawmakers introduced a special termination right that allowed landlords to end contracts concluded before December 2021 with effect from July 2024, without a notice period unless otherwise agreed. The contracts being ended typically ran 10 to 20 years, and the law gave the contracting operators no claim to damages.
How the court reasoned
The court found that the interference with property, occupational and freedom of action was proportionate. Harbarth pointed to the several years between the reform's adoption and its taking effect as part of that assessment. The legislature had also placed the burdens of ending the privilege where the direct benefits of the earlier cost-passing rule had fallen. Harbarth stressed, however, that the encroachment on the telecom companies' property guarantee was not far from the limits of what the constitution permits. The temporary termination right has since expired.
Effects on landlords, tenants and TV providers
Most landlords ended their bulk contracts with effect from July 2024. Tenants who wanted to keep receiving television then needed a contract of their own or had to join new bulk arrangements, which are billed separately from rent and carry no obligation to take part. Under the old practice, participation in the shared contract had been compulsory. TV providers had planned for contracts running many years and said the abrupt end disadvantaged them, which is the position the three operators took before the court.
What the ruling settles
The decision closes the constitutional challenge to the special termination right, which applied only to contracts concluded before December 2021. All three complaints were dismissed, so the court found the provision compatible with the Basic Law. Harbarth read out the judgment in Karlsruhe, where the First Senate rejected the complaints. The case remains on record under 1 BvR 1803/22.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- HandelsblattFederal Constitutional Court: New rules for TV contractsBundesverfassungsgericht: Neue Regeln für TV-Verträge - Karlsruhe weist Klagen ab · original in German
- Süddeutsche ZeitungNew rules for TV contractsNeue Regeln für TV-Verträge - Karlsruhe weist Klagen ab · original in German
- N-tvThe day: Free choice in television: Special termination right for cable contracts is lawfulDer Tag: Freie Wahl beim Fernsehen: Sonderkündigungsrecht von Kabelverträgen rechtens · original in German
- stern.deFree choice in television: Lawsuits against special terminations of cable contracts failFreie Wahl beim Fernsehen: Klagen gegen Sonderkündigungen von Kabelverträgen scheitern · original in German
- Stephan Harbarth
- President of the Federal Constitutional Court, who announced the First Senate's ruling in Karlsruhe
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar