Government · Warsaw
Kaczyński rejects Tribunal reset unless a presidential technical government is formed
PiS leader Jarosław Kaczyński said a Constitutional Tribunal reset would be acceptable only if the government were replaced by a presidential technical government. The Chancellery of the President has drafted a single bill, and talks continue on Thursday, 19 November, at 18:00.
AI text based on reports by NIEZALEZNA.PL, Nasz Dziennik and wpolityce.pl. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Kaczyński wrote on X that a reset would be acceptable only if the government were replaced by a presidential technical government, without which PiS finds the proposed solutions unacceptable.
KPRP head Zbigniew Bogucki said participants agree 'about 70%' on the proposed solutions, and the draft is built on the PSL project.
The third meeting of clubs and circles with Bogucki on the Tribunal is set for Thursday, 19 November, at 18:00, and the Civic Coalition and the Left are not attending.
Kaczyński says the mechanism for choosing new Tribunal judges gives the coalition of 13 December far-reaching control, while one outlet attributes that point to PiS MP Joanna Borowiak.

- 18 NovAfternoon meeting at the Chancellery of the President with parliamentary representatives
- 19 NovKaczyński sets his conditions for a reset in a post on X
- 19 NovThird meeting of clubs and circles with Bogucki on the Tribunal
Kaczyński's condition for a reset
Jarosław Kaczyński, leader of Law and Justice (PiS), set out his stance on a possible reset of the Constitutional Tribunal in a post on X on Thursday, 19 November. He said the Tribunal should return to operating within the law, but rejected any tolerance of lawbreaking, impunity or privileges, such as salaries and immunities, for those he described as having committed a coup. He wrote that a reset would be acceptable only if the government were replaced by a presidential technical government, one that would stop the breaking of the constitution and laws and hold honest elections on the constitutional date. He acknowledged that such a price would be high and very hard to accept, morally and politically, yet he still called it acceptable. He also argued there is no guarantee that the ruling coalition would stop breaking the constitution and laws after a reset.
“Without appointing a technical government, the proposed solutions are unacceptable for PiS.”
The draft from the Chancellery
Zbigniew Bogucki, head of the Chancellery of the President (KPRP), hosted representatives of some parliamentary forces on Wednesday afternoon, 18 November, to discuss the Tribunal. Afterwards he said the Chancellery had produced a single draft that combines proposals from different political groups, and he announced further talks for Thursday. According to him, the most far-reaching proposal, a PSL project on resetting the Tribunal's work, was substantially expanded with suggestions from other clubs and parliamentary circles. Bogucki said participants agree 'about 70%' on the proposed solutions. The next meeting is set for Thursday, 19 November, at 18:00, and it will be the third meeting of clubs and circles with Bogucki on the Tribunal. Representatives of the Civic Coalition and the Left are not taking part in these meetings.
Reactions in the PiS camp
Most replies under Kaczyński's post backed the party leader. Michał Wójcik, a former deputy justice minister, wrote that there should be no resets and that those who harmed the state must answer under criminal law. PiS MP Jan Mosiński said the Tribunal should return to operating lawfully. Kaczyński went further in his assessment of the draft. He argued that the mechanism for choosing new Tribunal judges gives the coalition of 13 December far-reaching control over the process, and that the patriotic camp would be left without influence. He summed up his view of the proposal in these words:
“The proposed reset would be a great success for those who are destroying our country.”
One outlet attributes the judge selection criticism to PiS MP Joanna Borowiak rather than to Kaczyński.
Next steps
The next step named so far is the Thursday meeting at 18:00, where talks will continue on the basis of the single Chancellery draft. Kaczyński's position leaves PiS outside any arrangement that does not include a presidential technical government, while the Civic Coalition and the Left remain absent from the meetings organised by Bogucki.
This article is part of a thread
Poland's Constitutional Tribunal leadership
What changed since this entry:
- 19/11Supreme Court resolution says unsworn judges cannot sit until Nawrocki takes their oaths
- 19/11Kaczyński demands a presidential technical government as price of a Tribunal reset
- 19/11Leśkiewicz says negotiators agreed about 70% of a joint solution, next round at 18:00
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- NIEZALEZNA.PLKaczyński does not agree to a reset without accountability. Comments leave no doubtKaczyński nie zgadza się na reset bez rozliczeń. Komentarze nie pozostawiają wątpliwości · original in Polish
- Nasz DziennikJarosław Kaczyński on the Constitutional TribunalJarosław Kaczyński o Trybunale Konstytucyjnym · original in Polish
- wpolityce.plPiS chairman firm on the TK! Words about a “thick line” were spokenPrezes PiS twardo w sprawie TK! Padły słowa o "grubej kresce" · original in Polish
- NIEZALEZNA.PLJarosław Kaczyński issues an ultimatum. There is one condition for a reset in the TribunalJarosław Kaczyński stawia ultimatum. Jest jeden warunek resetu w Trybunale · original in Polish
- Jarosław Kaczyński
- Leader of Law and Justice (PiS) who set out the party's conditions on a Tribunal reset in a post on X
- Zbigniew Bogucki
- Head of the Chancellery of the President (KPRP) who hosted the talks and drafted the single Tribunal proposal
- Michał Wójcik
- Former deputy justice minister who publicly backed Kaczyński's position
- Joanna Borowiak
- PiS member of parliament, named by one outlet as the source of the judge selection criticism
- Places
- Warsaw
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar