Transport · Berlin

Confidential German study recommends car toll on Autobahn to fund motorway upkeep

The study, prepared for the federal government and reported by Der Spiegel on Saturday, 21 November, says Autobahn GmbH may need new income by early 2034 even with 20 billion euros of permitted borrowing.

AI text based on reports by 7sur7, Telegraaf, RP Online and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Berlin · Germany
How it came to this
  1. June 2019European Court of Justice halts an earlier car toll plan as unlawful
  2. 21 NovDer Spiegel reports the confidential PD study recommending a car toll
  3. Early 2034Study says Autobahn GmbH must find new revenue at the latest

What the study recommends

A confidential study prepared for the German federal government recommends a toll for passenger cars to help finance the Autobahn network. Der Spiegel reported on Saturday, 21 November, that the document was drawn up by the public consultancy PD and is marked as classified. It is a cost-benefit study of a financing reform planned by Steffen Bilger (CDU) for the state-owned company Autobahn GmbH. The authors see that reform as an improvement on the status quo, but they doubt its revenue would cover long-term investment needs and borrowing costs. Under the reform, Autobahn GmbH would be allowed to borrow money itself and would receive part of the truck toll income in return. Even if its permitted debt were capped at 20 billion euros, the study says the company would face 'considerable pressure to raise revenue' by early 2034 at the latest.

Two alternatives and their scores

PD models two alternatives. In the first, Autobahn GmbH would keep all truck toll revenue instead of a share of it. In the second, it would keep its current truck toll share and also collect income from a 'newly introduced, route-based car toll'. Each option was given a percentage score relative to the overall economic benefit. The status quo scored 56.6 percent and Bilger's reform plans 65.8 percent, while a full truck toll reached 77.4 percent and a combined car and truck toll 79.9 percent.

Study scores by financing option%
Status quo
56.6 %
Bilger reform plans
65.8 %
Full truck toll
77.4 %
Car and truck toll
79.9 %

Data from the article text

According to the study, a car toll would let the company stay financially stable and service its debts through 2056, the last year of the period analysed.

Official position and earlier attempt

According to Telegraaf, a car toll is not officially on the federal government's table, and it is absent from the coalition agreement between the CDU/CSU and SPD. Bilger has reportedly said he received no instruction to prepare one. 7sur7 reports that he had earlier said a car toll was not on the agenda. Tagesspiegel recalls that the European Court of Justice halted an earlier car toll in June 2019 as unlawful. That plan would have offset the charge for domestic vehicle owners through vehicle tax but not for foreign drivers, which the court treated as discrimination.

Who would pay

Belgian and Dutch outlets focus on foreign motorists. 7sur7 writes that foreign-registered cars would be charged on the same basis as German drivers, and Telegraaf says Dutch motorists would most likely be affected as well. The study bases the charge on distance driven, but no amount has been set, and Telegraaf notes that the document does not say what rate would be needed to balance the budget. Telegraaf also reports that the study warns a car toll would likely lead to lawsuits and that its revenue could fluctuate.

Timeline of the funding gap

The study places the moment when Autobahn GmbH must raise income at early 2034 at the latest, and its analysis runs to 2056. The sequence below covers the 2019 court ruling, the Spiegel report and the early 2034 deadline.

Nothing has been decided yet, and any car toll would still need to clear political and legal hurdles.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar