Energy & Trade · Bayreuth

Ifo study finds Germany's five largest power producers used market power to raise prices in 2021-2022 crisis

A study by the Ifo Institute puts the extra revenue of Germany's five largest electricity producers at between 10.7 and 20.5 billion euros from September 2021 to the end of 2022, and says the price peaks cannot be explained by generation costs alone.

AI text based on reports by Notícias ao Minuto and N-tv. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Bayreuth · Germany
How it came to this
  1. Until September 2021Market prices and simulated competitive prices are practically the same
  2. September 2021Gap opens in the crisis period, with market prices averaging about 45 euros per megawatt-hour above simulated prices
  3. End of 2022Close of the period in which the five largest producers earned between 10.7 and 20.5 billion euros in additional revenue

What the Ifo study found

The Ifo Institute says the five largest electricity producers in Germany, RWE, LEAG, EnBW, Uniper and Vattenfall, used their market power to demand higher prices during the energy crisis of 2021 and 2022. According to the study, the price peaks of that period cannot be explained by higher generation costs alone. The institute calculates that these companies earned between 10.7 and 20.5 billion euros in additional revenue from September 2021 to the end of 2022 because of that market power. Till Fladung, a researcher at Ifo, locates the cause in the market structure as well as in the gas price shock.

“Record electricity prices were not solely a consequence of the gas price shock, but also of a structure that allows market power to be abused.”

Till Fladung

How the researchers measured the gap

Fladung and his co-author Anna Saile of the University of Bayreuth simulated prices for market situations in which prices form under competitive conditions. They then compared those simulated prices with the actual prices. Until September 2021 the two series were practically the same. From September 2021 onward, during the crisis, market prices averaged about 45 euros per megawatt-hour above the simulated prices. Even under the most conservative assumptions, such as significantly higher producer prices, the difference was still about 20 euros per megawatt-hour.

Price gap above simulated competitive pricesEUR/MWh
Average gap from September 2021
45 EUR/MWh
Gap under most conservative assumptions
20 EUR/MWh

Data from the article text

Market share and the case for change

The five companies together account for about 56 percent of Germany's conventional power plant capacity, according to Ifo. Because of that share, the institute argues, electricity supply cannot be guaranteed in many hours without the output of individual companies. Fladung and Saile recommend expanding storage capacity and flexibility, broadening ownership of power plants and controlling price formation more closely. The Ifo researchers also point to a development running in the opposite direction, namely the tender for new gas power plants.

Timeline of the price gap

The study describes three stages. Until September 2021, market and simulated prices were practically identical. From September 2021, the crisis period, the gap opened, and it continued until the end of 2022, the close of the period the study covers. The 45 euro figure is the average gap, while the 20 euro figure is the gap under the most conservative assumptions.

The gas plant tender

In the first round of the tender for new gas power plants, RWE and LEAG, the two largest companies on the German electricity market, won 94 percent of the subsidised capacity. The Ifo researchers said the law underlying the tender contains no cap per bidder of the kind the Federal Cartel Office (Bundeskartellamt) had proposed. They warn that this leads to even higher market concentration in the long term. Saile said that distortions in the market would be hard to correct later on. The study presents the tender as running counter to the measures it recommends.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Germany

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar