Government · Paris
France's Senate passes law presuming police weapon use lawful, 205 to 110
The Senate adopted the bill on Friday, 20 November, without amendments, completing its passage through parliament. Left senators said they will refer the law to the Constitutional Council to block its promulgation.
AI text based on reports by rmf24.pl, 7sur7, 20minutes and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Officers who fire are presumed to have acted lawfully, in a necessary situation and proportionately, and the presumption can be overturned by any contrary evidence, according to the text tabled by Eric Pauget.
The Senate voted 205 to 110 on Friday, 20 November, adopting the text the National Assembly had passed in early July with 313 votes to 199.
Left senators announced a referral to the Constitutional Council to block promulgation, while Muriel Jourda defended the reform and Patrick Kanner called it contrary to the interests of law enforcement.
Unions and youth organisations called protests for Saturday, 21 November, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez warned prefects of added tension after the Senate decision.
- 19 NovSenate debate runs late into Thursday evening
- 20 NovSenate adopts the bill 205 to 110 without amendments
- 21 NovProtests called by unions and youth organisations
Final approval in the Senate
The French Senate gave final approval on Friday, 20 November, to a bill that presumes police officers and gendarmes acted lawfully when they use their weapons. Senators voted 205 to 110 and made no changes to the text the National Assembly had passed in early July, when it was approved 313 to 199. The bill was introduced by Les Républicains deputy Eric Pauget and backed by the government, much of the centrist bloc and the National Rally (RN). The Senate debate ran late into Thursday evening, 19 November, with the left extending discussions despite accusations of obstruction, after the government had placed the bill on the agenda urgently. Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez welcomed the result as "a mark of trust toward police officers and gendarmes".
- Senate, in favour
- 205 votes
- Senate, against
- 110 votes
- National Assembly, in favour
- 313 votes
- National Assembly, against
- 199 votes
Data from the article text
What the presumption changes
The law does not widen the situations in which officers may fire. It changes how a shooting is judged afterwards. When a police officer or gendarme uses a weapon, the officer is presumed to have acted within the law, meaning in a necessary situation and proportionately. The presumption can be rebutted, but the burden of producing evidence falls on the party challenging the lawfulness, such as the injured person, their relatives or prosecutors. Any evidence to the contrary can overturn the presumption at any time. Left senators said the presumption could threaten basic civil rights and make it harder to hold officers accountable for abuses, while supporters argued it gives police and gendarmes stronger legal protection. Nuñez insisted the reform was the government's rather than the National Rally's and that it did not create a "presumption of legitimate self-defence" for police, even though the official title still uses that phrase.
Opposition and next steps
Left senators, who opposed the text throughout, announced they would refer it to the Constitutional Council to block its promulgation. Patrick Kanner, president of the Socialist senators, called the law "contrary to the interests of our law enforcement forces" and said it offered Marine Le Pen "a foothold". Sylvie Josserand, an RN senator, described the vote as "a parliamentary and ideological victory" for her party. Muriel Jourda, the Republicans chair of the Senate law committee, defended the reform in the chamber.
“The presumption of innocence has never prevented an investigation and has never prevented a conviction.”
Rights groups warn that without an automatic criminal investigation after a shooting causes injury or death, an officer could have time to build an alibi before any complaint is filed. Under the text, a criminal inquiry would follow a complaint from the victim or their relatives. Police unions, by contrast, say officers are left defenceless.
Protests and wider context
Unions and youth organisations have called protests for Saturday, 21 November, and Nuñez warned prefects that demonstrations could add tension after the Senate decision. Several thousand people had already protested against the bill in Paris in September. Student protests over social anger have turned violent several times, in particular on 17 October. The planned referral to the Constitutional Council would block promulgation of the law.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- rmf24.plFrench Senate passes controversial law on police use of weaponsFrancuski Senat przyjął kontrowersyjną ustawę o użyciu broni przez policję · original in Polish
- 7sur7France adopts presumption of legal use of weapons by law enforcementLa France adopte la présomption d'usage légal des armes par les forces de l'ordre · original in French
- 20minutesPresumption of legal use of weapons by police adopted by ParliamentLa présomption d'usage légal des armes par la police adoptée par le Parlement · original in French
- LaVanguardiaFrench police will have fewer restrictions to shootLa policía francesa tendrá menos restricciones para disparar · original in Spanish
- Laurent Nuñez
- French Interior Minister who welcomed the Senate vote and warned prefects about protests
- Eric Pauget
- Les Républicains deputy who introduced the bill
- Muriel Jourda
- Republicans chair of the Senate law committee who defended the reform in the chamber
- Patrick Kanner
- President of the Socialist senators who opposed the bill
- Sylvie Josserand
- National Rally senator who claimed the vote as a parliamentary and ideological victory
- Marine Le Pen
- Leader of the National Rally, whose party backed the bill
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar