Government · Fivemiletown and Belfast

Independent review finds Fivemiletown cattle cull lawful but with operational gaps

An independent review led by former Irish chief veterinary officer Martin Blake found the June cull of 51 cattle in Co Tyrone was lawful, but said officials gave insufficient weight to the public reaction and left a gap in clearing the sites.

AI text based on reports by RTE.ie, BBC and Evening Standard. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Fivemiletown, Belfast · United Kingdom
How it came to this
  1. May 2026Court finds the farmer guilty of animal welfare offences and orders him deprived of his animals
  2. 29 JunDaera's Humane Slaughter Team begins the cull on farmland near Fivemiletown
  3. 30 JunCull continues over the second day of the operation
  4. 10 NovIndependent review by Martin Blake published, finding the cull lawful

What the review found

An independent review led by Dr Martin Blake, Ireland's former chief veterinary officer, concluded that the cull of 51 cattle on farmland near Fivemiletown, Co Tyrone, was lawful and that shooting the animals in the field was an appropriate method. The review was commissioned by Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir after complaints from politicians and farmers about how Stormont's Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (Daera) carried out the operation. Blake concluded that planning and communications were weak and that the department did not give enough weight to anticipating local distress. The findings were published on 10 November 2026.

“In summary, the operational choice was justified in light of the legal, animal welfare and operational considerations identified.”

Martin Blake, former Irish chief veterinary officer

The court order and the lead-up

In May a court found the farmer guilty of animal welfare offences, including 13 charges of failing to dispose of an animal carcass and six charges of causing unnecessary suffering to an animal. The court ordered that he be deprived of his animals, and the Evening Standard reports a lifetime disqualification from keeping livestock. He had a two-week statutory window to appeal, and Daera allowed him a further week to arrange matters. When the Humane Slaughter Team and departmental officials arrived, he had arranged for 15 animals to be sold, which left 51 animals spread across three sites.

How the cull unfolded

Daera's Humane Slaughter Team carried out the cull on the land on 29 and 30 June, according to the Evening Standard. Most animals at two of the sites had been culled by 13:30 BST. When the operation reached the third site, where four animals remained in a field, members of the public watched, which led to a protest and a pause. A farmer then arrived offering to buy the animals, but they got out onto the road. After they were returned to the field, a veterinarian on scene said they were distressed and the operation had to be completed, which happened by 21:45. A specialist contractor removed the carcasses after the operation ended.

Gaps in the sweep and the public reaction

The review found a significant operational gap in how the animals were cleared from the three parcels of land. Some animals broke out of the holding, and one bull had to be shot off-site. Three calves were missed during the sweep, and one was later found with a neck wound that may be consistent with a bullet wound. Records did not show how many rounds the marksmen fired or how many animals needed a second, close-range shot. Blake also said that suspending the cull temporarily so some animals could be sold added complexity to an already difficult situation.

“However, deficiencies in planning, record keeping and communications weakened the assurances concerning the decision-making process.”

Martin Blake, former Irish chief veterinary officer

The review also identified a post-conviction procedural gap, including a lack of specific guidelines for implementing deprivation orders and divided management oversight of the Humane Slaughter Team.

Political fallout and next steps

The cull prompted an emergency committee meeting at Stormont and a protest, and farming leaders held a vote of no confidence in the minister. The Ulster Farmers' Union called for Muir to resign, while a motion of no confidence brought by the DUP failed, according to the Evening Standard. Muir told the Assembly he will publish an action plan on the review's findings and said he will implement all of its recommendations. The Ulster Farmers' Union said it would go through the report in detail.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar