Transport · El Dorado, Amarillo, and Washington
US air traffic control outage: Trump calls flight systems 'ancient' but 'safe'
On Friday, 20 November, Trump called US flight systems 'ancient' yet 'safe', a week after a four-hour nationwide ground stop triggered by a router outage on 13 November.
AI text based on reports by AP NEWS, BBC, Ars Technica and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The FAA halted US flights on Friday, 13 November, for about four hours, which BBC reporting describes as the longest such halt since 11 September 2001.
A router being installed at El Dorado, Arkansas, sent 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds, and 17 of 22 air route traffic control centres lost voice and ground communications.
Flight-tracking data cited in one account counts more than 15,000 flights delayed or cancelled on the day and about 1.5 million passengers affected, while another report counts more than 12,000 cancellations on the day and more than 20,000 over the weekend.
On Friday, 20 November, Trump said the outages were separate events, called the air traffic systems at least 55 years old, and pressed Congress to fund upgrades.
FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said investigators were 'very close' to the root cause, and Sean Duffy was expected to announce findings as soon as Friday, 20 November.
- 13 NovNationwide ground stop halts flights for about four hours after router flooding
- 15 NovFAA Q&A post describes 1,000 connection attempts every 4 to 5 seconds
- 19 NovBedford calls the telecom network a patchwork of archaic technology
- 20 NovTrump says outages were separate events and calls flight systems ancient
A four-hour halt across US airspace
The Federal Aviation Administration stopped flights across the United States on Friday, 13 November, in a nationwide ground stop that lasted about four hours. BBC reporting describes it as the longest such halt since the 11 September 2001 attacks. The trigger was a telecommunications upgrade in which a government contractor was swapping copper lines for fibre and installing a router. That router began flooding other equipment in the air traffic control system with 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds. Seventeen of the 22 air route traffic control centres lost voice and ground communications, and it took 45 minutes to pinpoint the source because maintenance is logged manually on paper.
Root cause and the scale of disruption
An initial FAA investigation identified a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, as the origin of the excess data. At El Dorado, the FAA's network service provider, L3Harris, was replacing a 25-year-old Cisco router with a Juniper Networks model when the flood began. It remains unclear whether the wire replacement or a fault in the router caused the failure. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said investigators were 'very close' to identifying the root cause, and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy was expected to present the findings at a news conference as soon as Friday, 20 November. The available sources do not yet report those findings.
Estimates of the fallout differ. Flight-tracking data cited in one account puts more than 15,000 US flights delayed or cancelled on the day, affecting about 1.5 million passengers. Another report counts more than 12,000 cancellations that day, more than 20,000 over the weekend, and about 3,500 aircraft forced to land, with over 1 million passengers affected.
Trump's response
On Friday, 20 November, President Donald Trump said recent technology outages affecting banks and government agencies were 'separate events' and blamed routine upgrades. He treated the FAA disruption differently, attributing it to an 'ancient' air traffic control system that he said needs an overhaul. Trump called the systems obsolete, said they were at least 55 years old, and noted that some towers were not in good structural shape. He pressed Congress to fund costly upgrades and argued that the system remains safe because it runs slowly.
“It's very safe. But it's safe for a different reason because we do it very slowly.”
Transportation leaders have repeatedly asked Congress for billions of dollars since the outage and have warned that without an overhaul, outages like this would continue.
Why the network is still old
Speaking at Honeywell Aerospace's American Aviation Leadership Summit in Washington on Thursday, 19 November, Bedford described the telephone network that carries flight data as a patchwork of archaic technology and said it must be replaced as quickly as possible while safety is maintained.
“We have a patchwork, archaic federal telephone network.”
Michael Huerta, a former FAA administrator during the Obama administration, pointed to funding as the root of the problem in an earlier interview.
“At its core, it's a money problem.”
Huerta said the agency has been asked to do more with less, and that older systems must keep running around the clock, every day of the year, while new technology is introduced. Former FAA officials say the older networks are fragile, costly to maintain because they are obsolete, and difficult to connect with modern equipment.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- AP NEWSTrump says recent outages are 'separate' incidents but 'under control'
- BBCTrump says US flight systems are 'ancient' but 'safe'
- Ars TechnicaHow FAA can modernize US national airspace system without emergency ground stops
- NPRWhy the U.S. air traffic control system still relies on an 'antique' network
- Donald Trump
- US President who said the outages were separate events and called the flight systems ancient but safe
- Bryan Bedford
- FAA Administrator who said investigators were very close to the root cause
- Sean Duffy
- US Transportation Secretary who was expected to announce the root-cause findings
- Michael Huerta
- Former FAA administrator during the Obama administration who blamed underfunding
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar