Music · Bangkok

Eurovision seeks answers after Malaysia's TV3 cut LGBTQ+ performers from Asia final

Malaysia's broadcaster TV3 appears to have swapped out Vice Ganda and Thai drag performers in its broadcast of the first Eurovision Song Contest Asia final in Bangkok on 14 November. The EBU said it was surprised and disappointed and will ask producer Voxovation for an explanation.

AI text based on reports by der Standard, RTE.ie, Press.pl and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Bangkok · Thailand
How it came to this
  1. 2018Mango TV removes Ireland's Eurovision entry performance from its coverage, and the EBU later ends its partnership with the broadcaster
  2. 14 NovFirst Eurovision Song Contest Asia final held in Bangkok, won by Carmelle of the Philippines
  3. 16 NovOnline footage of the Malaysian TV3 broadcast circulates and internet users call the cuts censorship
  4. 17 NovEBU says it is surprised and disappointed and will ask Voxovation for clarification

The final and the altered broadcast

The first Eurovision Song Contest Asia final was held in Bangkok on Saturday, 14 November, and Carmelle, the Philippine entrant, won it. The show was produced under licence from the EBU, the alliance of public broadcasters that holds Eurovision's rights. Footage that circulated online afterwards suggested that TV3, the Malaysian broadcaster, had changed its picture during the programme. Viewers in Malaysia reportedly saw a scoreboard instead of Vice Ganda, the Philippine comedian and television presenter who was announcing the Philippine jury votes. Vice Ganda is gay and identifies as non-binary, yet the international feed still showed the presenter giving the top score of 12 points to Aina Abdul, Malaysia's entrant. Several internet users called the cuts censorship and shared video clips to support that claim.

What was cut from the programme

The opening number, which showcased Thai culture with performers on street-food carts, reportedly had its Thai drag performers replaced by a wide shot taken during rehearsals. The Guardian could not review TV3's full broadcast because the livestream is no longer available online, so the extent of the edits cannot be independently confirmed. Martin Green, director of the Eurovision Song Contest, said the changes appeared to be confined to the Malaysian feed, while transmissions in other countries were unaffected. It remains unclear why the edits were made or whether they breached the broadcasting agreement tied to the competition. Neither the EBU nor Voxovation has said whether participating broadcasters must air the show unedited or what consequences would follow a breach.

Organisers and producer respond

Green said the EBU was surprised and disappointed to learn that the broadcast had been altered, and that it takes the matter seriously. The EBU plans to write to Voxovation, the company producing the Asian edition under licence, asking it to clarify what happened and to establish with TV3 why the changes were made. Voxovation has said it is aware of the concerns and is examining the matter with the Malaysian broadcaster so that it does not happen again. The Guardian also contacted TV3's parent company, Media Prima, for comment, and the sources contain no reply from it. The sources do not say whether the EBU has taken any step against TV3 or Media Prima so far.

Precedent and Malaysian law

The controversy echoes 2018, when Chinese broadcaster Mango TV cut Ryan O'Shaughnessy's performance of Together, Ireland's entry, from its coverage. The Chinese channel also dropped Albania's act and blurred a rainbow flag. The EBU later ended its partnership with Mango TV, arguing that the censorship clashed with its commitment to universality and inclusivity. O'Shaughnessy praised that step at the time, describing the contest as a celebration of diversity. Malaysia is among the most restrictive Asian countries on LGBTQ+ issues, where same-sex sexual relations are criminalised and carry sentences of up to 20 years in prison.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar