Diplomacy · Shenzhen, Berlin, and Moscow

Europe seeks Ukraine talks seat as Trump, Putin and Xi meet in Shenzhen

Russia's foreign ministry opposed EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas joining future Ukraine talks, while Berlin's allies pressed for a role after Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping met in Shenzhen.

AI text based on reports by Notícias ao Minuto, PÚBLICO, RTP and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Shenzhen, Berlin, Moscow · China, Germany, Russia
How it came to this
  1. 19 NovTrump, Putin and Xi Jinping meet in Shenzhen for about an hour and a half
  2. Berlin coalition meetingEuropean leaders and Zelensky meet the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin
  3. Return flight from ShenzhenTrump phones European leaders gathered in Berlin, according to sources cited by Axios
  4. 20 NovRussia's foreign ministry opposes Kaja Kallas taking part in future Ukraine talks

Shenzhen and Berlin meet on the same day

On Thursday, 19 November, Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping held a trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, China. Deutsche Welle reports that the leaders met for about an hour and a half and mostly discussed possible UN reforms, energy and nuclear weapons. At the same time, European leaders and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky gathered in Berlin with the Coalition of the Willing, a group of about 40 countries, Portugal among them, that give Kyiv military and financial support. The parallel summits exposed a dispute over who should take part in negotiations to end the war, and the Europeans rejected any deal reached without Kyiv and the European Union.

Trump's call to European leaders

Trump phoned European leaders from Air Force One on the flight back from Shenzhen. According to sources cited by Axios, he told them Putin wants to end the war and wants a deal closed. Bloomberg, the Washington Post, Politico and the Telegraph, citing people with knowledge of the call, reported that it was placed through the phone of Jared Kushner, Trump's son-in-law, who was in Berlin with special envoy Steve Witkoff to brief Europeans on the latest round of Russia-Ukraine talks. Those outlets said Trump stressed how much money Europe could save by halting support for Ukraine. The Telegraph added that Trump angrily criticised EU and Ukrainian plans to cover Kyiv's extra budget and military needs for 2027, estimated at 70 billion euros. A White House official told Politico, on condition of anonymity, that Trump was not urging allies to stop funding Ukraine.

Europe seeks a seat at the table

Russia's foreign ministry opposes the participation of Kaja Kallas, the former Estonian prime minister who serves as EU foreign policy chief, in future rounds of talks. Spokeswoman Maria Zakharova told a press conference that Kallas stands out in efforts to abort any peace initiative. Zakharova said Russia remains open to dialogue with anyone ready to contribute constructively, but saw no willingness among European leaders to negotiate. Kallas had offered to represent the EU in the Ukraine talks even though EU leaders had not chosen her. At an informal summit in Dublin, the 27 leaders ruled out a single representative and opted for a delegation of the E5 countries (Germany, France, Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom) plus representatives of the European Commission and European Council. Kallas said she stands by her words and is willing to take on the role, while noting that leaders can always decide differently. Russian deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov said Moscow is still waiting for an EU reply to Vladimir Putin's invitation to visit Moscow.

Security guarantees and the cost of the war

Chancellor Friedrich Merz argued that once peace is reached in Ukraine, Europe must be safer, with a strong European pillar in NATO. He said the sequence should be peace in Ukraine first and euro-Atlantic security arrangements afterwards, and called Russia's maximalist demands unrealistic. Those demands date back to December 2021 and include a return of the allies to the 1997 borders. Merz also said more than 50,000 Russian soldiers died in October alone, a figure he compared with the total losses of US troops in the Vietnam War. Jared Kushner said Trump is open to offering Ukraine a protection mechanism similar to Article 5 of the NATO treaty, but that it must serve US interests. António Costa, president of the European Council, said only a peace that respects Ukraine's sovereignty will last.

What comes next

Merz said a meeting of Ukrainian, Russian, European and US leaders should take place soon, with the United Arab Emirates cited as a possible venue. Kushner said he believes Trump returned from China convinced that peace is achievable, and that the US president will explain how the war could end at the right moment. Zelensky insisted that European representatives take part in the coming rounds. The Danish prime minister said Putin would feel more courageous after meeting the US and Chinese presidents.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Organizations
European Union

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar