Government · London and Manchester

Nine English police forces seek emergency state aid as reform row over mega-forces grows

Nine forces in England have asked for exceptional financial support as chiefs warn officers are retreating from the streets. Separately, 29 police and crime commissioners have written to Andy Burnham urging him to stop forced mergers into larger regional forces.

AI text based on reports by Evening Standard, The Independent, BBC and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

London, Manchester · United Kingdom
How it came to this
  1. 13 NovLetter dated 13 November from 29 PCCs and two deputy mayors to Andy Burnham
  2. 16 NovGuardian reports nine forces seeking exceptional financial support
  3. 17 NovChris Philp due to address police chiefs on Tuesday

Nine forces seek emergency funding

Nine forces in England have asked central government for exceptional financial support (EFS), a temporary state scheme for local bodies under severe financial pressure. Paul Sanford, the Norfolk chief constable who leads finance for the National Police Chiefs' Council (NPCC), named them as Durham, Cleveland, Greater Manchester, Wiltshire, Bedfordshire, South Yorkshire, Gloucestershire, Lincolnshire and Norfolk. The Home Office declined to confirm how many forces had applied and will decide whether they receive extra money or whether councils may raise bills instead.

“Policing is in worse financial shape now than it has been for decades.”

Paul Sanford, norfolk chief constable and NPCC finance lead

Sanford said the forces that applied believe they are close to a tipping point, beyond which core services can no longer be sustained. The Home Office puts police funding at £18.5bn and points to a Financial Resilience Framework it set up to assess resilience consistently. The government says it has already raised forces' money in real terms, while chiefs answer that demand and population have both grown. Officer numbers stood at 148,536 in June 2024 and fell to 147,822 by March this year, and senior officers expect a further decline.

Officer numbers cited by the Guardian, June 2024 and March 2026officers
2024-06
148536 officers
2026-03
147822 officers

Data from the article text

Early releases and a widening gap

An early release scheme will let 5,000 prisoners out ahead of schedule over the next year to ease overcrowding in jails, and it is among the biggest pressures on force budgets. The NPCC estimates that the scheme could raise crime by up to 6%, adding to demand on officers. It now projects the funding gap for forces by 2030 at £4.3bn, rising from £3bn. Forces used reserves worth £300m over the last year, with some of that spent on investment and some needed to keep services running.

Projected police funding gap by 2030£bn
Earlier projection
3 £bn
Current projection
4.3 £bn

Data from the article text

Mega-forces and council tax

Ministers are considering proposals to cut the 43 forces in England and Wales to as few as nine. A report by former Metropolitan Police commissioner Lord Hogan-Howe for the Home Office, due next month, is understood to recommend nine superforces based on the nine counter-terror policing regions, though no final decision has been made. Another option under discussion would reduce the number of forces to 20. Sir Mark Rowley has proposed between eight and 10 regional forces, and the plans are not yet published.

Under the proposals, the police precept, which forms part of council tax bills and is currently set by local authorities, would be standardised across each region. Some areas with below-average bills could see a rise of up to £70 for an average Band D household, while areas paying more could see falls.

Commissioners push back

A letter dated 13 November, signed by 29 police and crime commissioners and two deputy mayors for policing, asks Andy Burnham to step in and stop forced mergers, while accepting voluntary mergers where the public backs them. Hampshire commissioner Donna Jones warned that a single chief constable would cover an area stretching from the Essex border to the New Forest. Surveys by the Thames Valley and Hampshire commissioners found more than 70% of respondents opposed mergers, although the samples were open to anyone and are not representative. Rowley has rejected that case, arguing that merging forces would cut duplication.

“We have 43 overstretched forces trying to do too much, with too little.”

Mark Rowley, metropolitan Police Commissioner

Reform debate and the Conservative claim

Gavin Stephens, chair of the NPCC, used a speech at the annual conference to back fewer, larger forces alongside a national police service covering counter-terrorism, some fraud and serious gang crime. He said the 43-force model creates a postcode lottery in technology and specialist support, and that officers sometimes retype information into incompatible systems. He cited a 7% fall in homicide and an 8% fall in knife-enabled crime in the year to March 2026.

“We cannot afford a complacent nostalgia.”

Gavin Stephens, chairman of the National Police Chiefs' Council

The Conservatives claim Shabana Mahmood's police reforms could mean 130,000 fewer crimes solved. Chris Philp is due to make the argument in a speech to police chiefs on Tuesday, 17 November, saying that mega-forces would weaken the response to everyday offences.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar