Government · Bucharest and Strasbourg
Romanian top court rejects Danileț's bid to annul 2019 sanction after ECHR win
Romania's High Court of Cassation and Justice refused on 16 November 2026 to annul a 2019 pay-cut sanction against Cristi Danileț. The European Court of Human Rights had ruled in his favour in December 2025.
AI text based on reports by Stirile ProTV, HotNews.ro, G4Media.ro and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The five-judge ICCJ panel on 16 November 2026 rejected Cristi Danileț's request to annul the 2019 CSM sanction, and the decision is final.
The court found the 5% pay cut for two months had limited effects, exhausted shortly after the ruling, and the sanction was later struck off by law.
The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights ruled 10 votes to 7 on 15 December 2025 that Article 10 was violated, and the ICCJ says that finding remains binding.
- February 2024European Court of Human Rights rules that Romania erred
- 15 DecGrand Chamber confirms the violation by 10 votes to 7
- 16 NovICCJ rejects the revision request, decision is final
The ruling
Romania's High Court of Cassation and Justice (ICCJ) on Monday, 16 November 2026, rejected a request from former judge Cristi Danileț to annul a 2019 disciplinary sanction through a revision procedure. A five-judge panel made the decision, and the ruling is final. The Superior Council of Magistracy (CSM) had cut Danileț's salary by 5% for two months over two Facebook posts. The European Court of Human Rights had ruled in December 2025 that Romania violated his freedom of expression, yet the domestic court did not reopen the case.
The court's communiqué stressed that the Strasbourg judgment is not in question.
“The ruling does not call into question the finding of the European Court, but concerns exclusively the exceptional conditions set by law for revision.”
Why the sanction stands
The panel held that a legal requirement for revision was not met: the existence of serious consequences that continue to arise from the violation. The court said the 5% pay cut had limited effects, which were exhausted shortly after the ruling, and that the sanction was later struck off by law. In assessing those effects it took into account Danileț's financial situation. It also found that the challenged decision had no influence on other rulings concerning his disciplinary liability. The reasoning concerns the current effects of the sanction rather than the seriousness of the violation found in Strasbourg.
The communiqué also said the Grand Chamber's judgment binds the Romanian state and all its authorities, including the courts.
“The criteria set by the Grand Chamber on freedom of expression for judges are a benchmark that Romanian courts apply unconditionally.”
The full reasoning will be published after it is drafted.
Danileț's response
Danileț reacted on Facebook in a post titled 'ICCJ violates human rights again', arguing that the court had once more violated his rights. He wrote that the Judicial Inspection investigated two posts but referred only one for disciplinary trial, while the CSM sanctioned him for both. He said 18 judges from the Judicial Inspection, the CSM and the ICCJ were involved in his sanction and that none of them would answer for it. He listed financial losses he says he cannot recover, including interest on the withheld money and his lawyers' and travel costs.
He wrote that
“I cannot receive the money illegally withheld from my salary”
He noted that the disciplinary record will eventually be erased with the passing of time, which he said is not the same thing for him. He ended the post with a message addressed directly to President Nicușor Dan.
Case history
Ziare reports that the case began with two Facebook posts Danileț published in January 2019 about state institutions and the judiciary. In his own list of procedural steps, the ICCJ upheld the sanction in May 2020 and rejected a challenge on procedural grounds in December 2020. He says Parliament abrogated the disciplinary offence in November 2022. The European Court of Human Rights ruled in February 2024 that Romania had wronged him, and its Grand Chamber confirmed the violation on 15 December 2025 by ten votes to seven. Romania was ordered to pay 9,705.44 euros in costs. Danileț's post says the ICCJ postponed its decision three times before ruling on 16 November 2026.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Stirile ProTVICCJ refused to annul a sanction applied to Cristi Danileț, although Romania was condemned at the ECHRÎCCJ a refuzat să anuleze o sancțiune aplicată lui Cristi Danileț, deși România a fost condamnată la CEDO · original in Romanian
- HotNews.roCristi Danileț's reaction after the ICCJ decision regarding his sanction. “Thank you, Mr. President, for watching over the violation of human rights”Reacția lui Cristi Danileț după decizia ÎCCJ privind sancționarea sa. "Mulțumesc, domnul președinte, că vegheați la încălcarea drepturilor omului" · original in Romanian
- HotNews.roLast-minute decision of the supreme court in the case of former judge Cristi Danileț, after he won the lawsuit against Romania at the ECHRDecizie de ultimă oră a instanței supreme în cazul fostului judecător Cristi Danileț, după ce acesta a câștigat la CEDO procesul împotriva României · original in Romanian
- G4Media.roÎnalta Curte condusă de Lia Savonea refuză să anuleze sancțiunea aplicată lui Cristi Danileț de CSM în 2019, tot sub conducerea Lieri Savonea / ICCJ invocă în motivație "efectele reduse" ale sancțiunii având în vedere averea lui Danileț, și susține că verdictul nu contrazice verdictul favorabil dat de CEDO în cazul fostului judecător
- Cristi Danileț
- Former Romanian judge whose 2019 disciplinary sanction was at issue in the revision request
- Lia Savonea
- Head of the ICCJ, who led the CSM when it imposed the 2019 sanction
- Nicușor Dan
- President of Romania, addressed in Danileț's post
- Places
- Bucharest, Romania, Strasbourg
- Organizations
- Meta Platforms
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar