Diplomacy · Antalya
Russia and Vatican push to drop gender references at COP31 climate talks
Diplomats told POLITICO that Russia and the Vatican are rejecting most mentions of 'gender' in COP31 negotiating rooms in Turkey, while the EU presses them to drop their objections.
AI text based on reports by POLITICO, TheJournal.ie, Süddeutsche Zeitung and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Four diplomats told POLITICO that Russia and the Vatican are rejecting most mentions of 'gender' in the COP31 talks in Antalya, with Argentina and Paraguay backing them.
The EU has called on the blockers to drop their objections and keep previously agreed language, including the Paris Agreement's 'gender-responsive' wording.
The UN says crossing the 1.5C limit agreed in Paris in 2015 is imminent, and Copernicus says 2026 temperatures are virtually certain to exceed 1.5C above pre-industrial levels.
A draft released on Monday, 16 November, covers finance for poorer countries, adaptation after extreme weather and faster transition to clean energy.
Gender language in the negotiations
Four diplomats told POLITICO that Russia and the Vatican are working together to block references to gender recognition in the COP31 talks in Antalya, Turkey. In the rooms where ministers and officials are hammering out texts on finance and clean energy, the two countries are rejecting most mentions of the word "gender". The diplomats asked not to be named because their governments had not authorized them to speak to the media. They suspected the move is driven by opposition to LGBTQ+ rights, and said the changes would narrow definitions in COP31 texts so as to exclude transgender people. One negotiator described the aim as replacing "gender" with "women", without accepting even a reference to "all women".
Support and silence
Argentina and Paraguay back the Vatican and Russia, according to two of the diplomats. The Vatican press office, Russia's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Argentinian foreign ministry and Paraguay's environment ministry did not respond to requests for comment. Russia and the Vatican have found common cause on this issue despite being at odds on other global affairs.
The European Union has called on the blockers to drop their objections and stick to language already agreed. A member of the EU delegation in Antalya accused a few parties of a growing, coordinated pushback against principles including human rights and gender equality.
Why gender sits in climate texts
Researchers have found that global warming disproportionately affects women and girls, including through higher gender-based violence and health risks during pregnancy. Marginalized groups and people facing discrimination are generally more exposed to climate impacts, scientists say. The decade-old Paris Agreement calls for "gender-responsive" policies, meaning policies that account for how climate change affects people of different genders.
A wider debate on the summit's worth
Eamon Ryan, the former Green Party leader and former climate minister, returned from Antalya and told RTÉ's Drivetime that people should not give up on climate action. Asked whether COP is still worthwhile, he said the vast majority of the roughly 100,000 people there would say it is.
“I think the vast majority would say it is still worth it, even though the progress is not fast enough”
Ryan said climate action has fallen out of public attention in recent years and that without COP it would hardly reach the news. The UN now says crossing the 1.5C limit agreed in Paris in 2015 is imminent. Copernicus said earlier in November that global temperatures are virtually certain to exceed 1.5C above pre-industrial levels in 2026. Activists including Greta Thunberg argue COP summits have become less effective, while climate policy experts say the talks have helped reduce projected warming and that real progress depends on action between summits.
Draft texts and the United States
A draft released on Monday, 16 November, focuses on finance for poorer countries, adaptation after a year of extreme weather and proposals to speed the shift to clean energy. The United States is not even represented at the Antalya conference, and a few American climate advocates are there hoping for the day Trump is no longer in office. Yassamin Ansari, a Democrat in the House, is among lawmakers who travelled to Turkey to reassure allies that the US can still play a positive role. Ryan also said that Donald Trump is, in a strange way, one of the greatest advertisements for climate action, because the alternative is visible.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- POLITICORussia, Vatican lead gender backlash at climate summit
- TheJournal.ieEamon Ryan says we 'can't give up' on climate action
- Süddeutsche ZeitungWe have no right to give up"Wir haben kein Recht aufzugeben · original in German
- Bloomberg BusinessThe Democrat Telling the World the US Is Still a Climate Ally
- Eamon Ryan
- Former Green Party leader and former climate minister who returned from COP31 and spoke on RTÉ's Drivetime
- Donald Trump
- US president whose stance on climate action was cited by Ryan and whom activists hope will no longer hold office
- Greta Thunberg
- Climate activist who argues COP summits have become increasingly ineffective
- Yassamin Ansari
- Democrat in the US House who travelled to the Turkey talks to reassure allies that the US can still play a positive role
- Places
- Antalya, Turkey, United States
- Organizations
- United Nations
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar