Government · Mainz, Munich, and Berlin
Söder demands immediate cold progression relief; Schnieder calls it unserious without financing plan
Bavarian Minister-President Markus Söder wants full compensation for cold progression now, a cost of about 4.2 billion euros in 2027. Rhineland-Palatinate Minister-President Gordon Schnieder rejects the demand unless its backers say how it would be financed.
AI text based on reports by stern.de, Süddeutsche Zeitung, Handelsblatt and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Söder wants full compensation for cold progression now, which would cost federal government, states and municipalities about 4.2 billion euros in 2027.
Gordon Schnieder says the demand is unserious without an honest financing plan and that any extra relief must be funded entirely from federal money.
The 2027 federal budget gets its final Bundestag deliberation in the week of 23 November 2026 and a vote on Friday, 27 November, while Thorsten Frei says the offset could still be decided retroactively next year.
In the night from 17 to 18 November the coalition committee agreed to cut the electricity tax, initially until the end of 2027, with cold progression left unresolved.

- 22 NovSchnieder rejects the demand as unserious without a financing plan
- Week of 23 November 2026Bundestag holds final deliberation on the 2027 federal budget
- 27 NovPlanned Bundestag vote on the 2027 federal budget
Söder wants immediate relief
Bavarian Minister-President Markus Söder (CSU) is calling for an immediate offset of cold progression, the hidden tax burden that arises because income tax does not account for inflation. Earners whose pay only keeps pace with rising prices still move into higher tax brackets, even though their purchasing power has not grown. In an interview with Bild am Sonntag, Söder argued that the coalition should not give up what he called a good political practice of many years, especially in economically difficult times. He framed the matter as one of justice and credibility, and warned that the democratic centre must be able to act.
“We urgently need compensation for cold progression now.”
He said Bavaria is ready to bear part of the cost and that the offset has to be a joint effort of the federal government and the states. A full offset in 2027 would cost the federal government, the states and the municipalities a combined 4.2 billion euros. Handelsblatt splits that into 1.8 billion euros for the federal government, 1.8 billion for the states and 0.6 billion for municipalities, while Focus gives a different split of 1.8 billion for the federal government and 2.2 billion for the states.
- Federal government
- 1.8 billion euros
- States (Länder)
- 1.8 billion euros
- Municipalities
- 0.6 billion euros
Data from the article text
Schnieder rejects the push
Rhineland-Palatinate Minister-President Gordon Schnieder (CDU) rejected the demand. He told Rheinische Post that everyone agrees full compensation is right in principle, but that the demand is simply unserious unless its backers say honestly how it would be financed.
“Such a demand is simply unserious, however, if one does not honestly say how it is to be financed.”
Schnieder said the state budgets are set and the federal budget has been negotiated and is now in parliament and the coalition committee. Anyone who wants extra relief at short notice, he argued, must fund it entirely from federal money. He also asked whether the Mütterrente III should take priority, a project Handelsblatt describes as a prestige project of Söder. Handelsblatt reported little willingness among the other states to give up tax revenue, noting that many have far less room and that Bavaria is by far the largest contributor to the fiscal equalisation between states.
Coalition deals and the budget clock
In the night from 17 to 18 November, the coalition committee agreed to cut the electricity tax, initially limited to the end of 2027, with any permanent cut dependent on sustainable counter-financing. The committee reached no result on cold progression because it concentrated on lowering energy prices, CDU general secretary Franziska Hoppermann said, adding that offsetting it remains a big goal for the Union. Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil (SPD) argues that the planned income tax reform already compensates cold progression for people with low and middle incomes, while higher earners pay more. Handelsblatt reports that Söder is also putting pressure on Klingbeil and Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU).
The 2027 federal budget is due for its final Bundestag deliberation in the week of 23 November 2026, with the vote scheduled for Friday, 27 November. Handelsblatt notes that an initiative now would probably come too late for that budget. Thorsten Frei, leader of the Union parliamentary group, has said the offset could still be decided retroactively during next year if the money is available.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- stern.deSchnieder finds Söder's tax push unseriousSchnieder findet Söder-Vorstoß zu Steuern unseriös · original in German
- Süddeutsche ZeitungSchnieder finds Söder's tax push unseriousSchnieder findet Söder-Vorstoß zu Steuern unseriös · original in German
- HandelsblattHidden tax increase: Söder does not let up on cold progressionVersteckte Steuererhöhung: Söder lässt bei kalter Progression nicht locker · original in German
- RP OnlineCompensation for creeping tax increase: Schnieder calls Söder's demand simply unseriousAusgleich schleichende Steuererhöhung: Schnieder nennt Söders Forderung "schlicht unseriös · original in German
- Markus Söder
- Bavarian Minister-President and CSU leader who demands immediate compensation for cold progression
- Gordon Schnieder
- Rhineland-Palatinate Minister-President (CDU) who rejects the demand
- Lars Klingbeil
- SPD finance minister who argues the planned income tax reform compensates cold progression for low and middle incomes
- Friedrich Merz
- Chancellor (CDU) under pressure from Söder over the issue
- Thorsten Frei
- Leader of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group who says the offset could be decided retroactively
- Franziska Hoppermann
- CDU general secretary who says no result on cold progression was reached
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar