Government · Barcelona
Barcelona court annuls Generalitat telework ban for senior officials, clashing with Monday ruling
A Barcelona administrative court has declared void the Generalitat's decision to withdraw telework from deputy director generals, a day after another court upheld the ban. The Catalan high court TSJC must now settle which ruling applies.
AI text based on reports by eldiario.es, LaVanguardia, EL PAÍS and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
A Barcelona court annulled the instruction on Tuesday, 17 November 2026, a day after another court upheld the telework ban on Monday, 16 November 2026.
The judge said he could not declare the instruction void and opened a question of illegality for the TSJC. The Generalitat has asked the TSJC to unify criteria.
About 450 holders of these posts or equivalent rank could be affected, but only about 300 had requested and used telework, and none had teleworked since early 2025.
Four lawsuits were filed against the resolutions, two have been decided, and two judgments are still pending, with the ban in force meanwhile.
- 7 JanInstruction 1/2025 removes telework for directors general and equivalent posts
- 16 NovBarcelona court upholds the telework ban for senior officials
- 17 NovSecond Barcelona court annuls the instruction for deputy director generals
Two rulings in two days
A Barcelona administrative court has declared void the Generalitat's decision to withdraw telework from deputy director generals and equivalent posts, a judgment reported on Tuesday, 17 November 2026. The court found that the underlying instruction changed a 2020 decree regulating teleworking across the Catalan public administration, and that a measure of lower rank cannot alter a rule of higher rank. A different Barcelona court had upheld the ban on Monday, 16 November 2026, ruling that remote work is a reversible organisational arrangement rather than an individual right. Reports differ on the number of that court, which appears as 14 in one account and 12 in another. The two judgments point in opposite directions on the same measure, so the dispute now heads to the Superior Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC).
The January 2025 instruction
Albert Dalmau, the counsellor for the Presidency, issued instruction 1/2025 on 7 January 2025 to all departments. It removed telework for directors general, secretaries general and equivalent posts, arguing that these roles need effective and constant on-site presence for fluid communication and supervision. Each department then adopted its own resolution applying the measure. Staff had long worked a hybrid model that predated the pandemic and was consolidated during Covid lockdowns, and in 2021 the civil service board approved a structure of two days on site and three days teleworking for public employees. Four lawsuits challenged the resulting decisions: one from officials in the Economy department, one from officials in Business and Work, one from an individual worker and one from a cross-departmental group of senior officials.
Who is affected
La Vanguardia reports that the rulings could affect about 450 staff who hold these posts or have the recognised rank. Only about 300 of them had requested and used telework, and none had been teleworking since early 2025. Reports differ on the size and department of the challenges, with one account citing 21 officials against the Economy department and another citing seven officials from Business and Work. Two of the four lawsuits have now been decided, and the ban remains in force while the rest are pending.
- Holders of these posts or equivalent rank
- 450 people
- Had requested and used telework
- 300 people
Data from the article text
What happens next
The judge who annulled the instruction said he lacked power to strike down a measure of that normative character, so he opened the door to a question of illegality that the TSJC must resolve. The Generalitat has asked the TSJC to unify criteria, and until then the ban stays in place, requiring senior officials to attend their offices in person each day. Government sources say the rulings do not address whether deputy directors can telework given their functions, a position the Generalitat maintains. Two further judgments are still pending and could deepen the split between courts. The judge also decided that neither party should pay costs, citing genuine doubts of fact and law.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- eldiario.esOpposing rulings on banning telework for senior government officials: one judge endorses it and another annuls itSentencias opuestas sobre prohibir el teletrabajo a los altos funcionarios del Govern: un juez lo avala y otro lo anula · original in Spanish
- LaVanguardiaThe TSJC must resolve whether it was legal to withdraw telework from the deputy directors of the GeneralitatEl TSJC deberá resolver si fue legal retirar el teletrabajo a los subdictores de la Generalitat · original in Spanish
- EL PAÍSThe Generalitat maintains the telework ban for senior officials until the justice system unifies criteriaLa Generalitat mantiene la prohibición de teletrabajo para los altos cargos hasta que la justicia unifique criterios · original in Spanish
- ABC TU DIARIO EN ESPAÑOLA court endorses telework for senior officials of the Generalitat after the ruling that supported its revocationUn juzgado avala el teletrabajo para altos cargos de la Generalitat tras el fallo que respaldó su revocación · original in Spanish
- Albert Dalmau
- Counsellor for the Presidency of the Generalitat who issued instruction 1/2025 ending telework for senior posts
- Salvador Illa
- Head of the Generalitat government whose administration maintains the telework ban
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar