Business · The Hague
Dutch court temporarily bans BYD Ti 7 sales in EU over Land Rover Defender likeness
A court in The Hague has temporarily barred BYD from selling its Ti 7 SUV in the European Union, finding it too similar to the Land Rover Defender. Jaguar Land Rover must start a main proceeding within six months to make the ban permanent.
AI text based on reports by The Telegraph, vrtnws.be, La Libre.be and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
A Dutch court imposed a temporary sales ban on BYD's Ti 7 SUV in the European Union on Friday, 20 November, finding it too closely resembles the Land Rover Defender type L663.
Jaguar Land Rover must start a main proceeding within six months to make the interim ban permanent, or the ban may lose its force.
JLR asked for a sales ban in the United Kingdom as well, but the court said it can only order a ban for the EU, leaving part of the claim unanswered.
BYD said it had no concrete plans to sell the Ti 7 in the European Union, while the company had announced it wanted to introduce the model in the UK.
- 2019JLR wins a case after a three-year lawsuit to ban JMC from selling the Landwind X7
- 20 NovDutch court temporarily bans BYD from selling the Ti 7 in the EU
- Within six monthsDeadline for JLR to start main proceedings, or the interim ban may lose its force
The ruling
A court in The Hague has temporarily barred BYD from selling its Ti 7 SUV in the European Union. The judge, sitting in urgent summary proceedings, partly granted the claim brought by Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), which argued that the Chinese model infringed its intellectual property rights. The ruling was handed down on Friday, 20 November. The judge found that the Ti 7 resembles the Land Rover Defender type L663 too closely.
Why the court found a match
The court pointed to shared design elements such as the rounded shoulders and rounded corners of the two vehicles. BYD had argued that the differences were clear enough to set the cars apart, but the court disagreed.
“These characteristic elements dominate the overall impression.”
The court added that the differences BYD had pointed to were not conspicuous enough to noticeably affect that overall impression. BYD had said earlier that it had no concrete plans to bring the Ti 7 to the EU market.
Scope and limits of the ban
The prohibition applies only within the EU. JLR had also asked for a sales ban in the United Kingdom, but the court said it could only impose such a ban for the EU. As a result, an important part of JLR's request remains unanswered. The Ti 7 is the model BYD had announced for introduction in the UK, which JLR cited as the step that prompted its lawsuit.
What happens next
Because the decision came in urgent summary proceedings, it is interim. JLR must start a main proceeding on the merits within six months to make the ban final. If it does not, the court said the ban imposed on BYD could lose its force. The deadline therefore falls about six months after the ruling.
An earlier case
JLR has pursued Chinese carmakers over alleged copying before. In 2019 it won a case after a lawsuit lasting three years, banning Jiangling Motor Corporation (JMC) from selling a model. That model, the Landwind X7, was said to resemble the Range Rover Evoque. The sequence of key dates is shown below.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- The TelegraphChina's BYD banned from selling 'copycat Land Rover' in Europe
- vrtnws.beJudge rules in favor of Land Rover: BYD temporarily banned from selling “Chinese Defender clone” in European UnionRechter geeft Land Rover gelijk: BYD mag 'Chinese Defender-kloon' voorlopig niet verkopen in Europese Unie | VRT NWS Nieuws · original in Dutch
- La Libre.beBYD cannot sell one of its models in the European Union for nowBYD ne peut pas vendre pour l'instant l'un de ses modèles dans l'Union européenne · original in French
- de VolkskrantCar manufacturer BYD may not sell clone of Land Rover Defender in EUAutofabrikant BYD mag kloon van Land Rover Defender niet verkopen in EU · original in Dutch
- Places
- The Hague, Netherlands, China
- Organizations
- European Union, BYD Auto
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar