Elections · Karlsruhe and Berlin

Federal Constitutional Court rules Wednesday on BSW bid for 2025 Bundestag recount

The Federal Constitutional Court will publish its decision at 9:30 on Wednesday, 18 November, on the BSW's complaint seeking a nationwide recount of the 2025 Bundestag election, where the party missed the five percent threshold by 9,529 votes.

AI text based on reports by tagesschau.de, Spiegel Online, Handelsblatt and other publishers. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Karlsruhe, Berlin · Germany
How it came to this
  1. 23 FebBundestag election: BSW wins 4.981 percent of second votes, 9,529 votes short of entering parliament
  2. May 2025Court rejects organ disputes in which the BSW sought a review of the close result
  3. 18 DecBundestag rejects the BSW objection and refuses a recount
  4. 18 NovFederal Constitutional Court publishes its decision on the BSW complaint

What the court will decide

The Federal Constitutional Court will publish its decision at 9:30 on Wednesday, 18 November, on a complaint by the Bündnis Soziale Gerechtigkeit und Wirtschaftliche Vernunft (BSW), the party founded by Sahra Wagenknecht. The party was renamed in October and still uses the abbreviation BSW. It asks the court to declare the official result of the Bundestag election of 23 February 2025 invalid and to order a nationwide recount. The BSW won 4.981 percent of the second votes, just under the five percent threshold, and was 9,529 votes short of entering parliament. The complaint, filed as case 2 BvC 4/26, targets the Bundestag's decision of 18 December 2025 to reject the party's objection and refuse a recount.

Under the Basic Law, the Bundestag must first rule on election objections, and only then can the Constitutional Court hear a complaint. The court will not hold an oral hearing and will issue a resolution rather than a judgment, which Berliner Zeitung notes is not unusual for election complaints. The Second Senate, chaired by Vice President Ann-Katrin Kaufhold, is responsible for the case.

The party's counting claims

After the election the BSW carried out its own checks and reported finding 'anomalies'. Its votes were allegedly assigned to the similarly named Bündnis Deutschland, and ballots on which only the second vote for the BSW was marked were wrongly declared invalid, even though a cross on the first vote is not required in federal elections. The party also says valid crosses were overlooked because it was placed far down the ballot. Its own projection puts the potential of wrongly counted BSW votes at about 33,000. The complaint further points to differences between the preliminary and official results, in which the BSW gained more than 4,000 votes, and argues that corrections were made only locally and selectively.

Votes missing for the threshold vs BSW miscount estimatevotes
Votes missing for the threshold (official result)
9529 votes
BSW estimate of potentially miscounted votes (about)
33000 votes

Data from the article text

Wagenknecht's warning and the stakes

Wagenknecht told the Deutsche Presse-Agentur that the current Bundestag may not have been constituted lawfully, and that the party cannot put more evidence of counting errors on the table without access to the ballot papers.

“Everything points to Merz having become chancellor unlawfully, and the current Bundestag not being constituted in line with the constitution.”

Sahra Wagenknecht, founder of the BSW and a complainant in the case before the Constitutional Court

The BSW believes it should hold 35 seats, which would redistribute all mandates and leave the black-red coalition without its own majority. Berliner Zeitung reports that the coalition currently has a lead of just twelve seats. Commenting to that paper on the decision to forgo a hearing, Wagenknecht said that such a move would only be understandable in one case.

“That would only be understandable if the Federal Constitutional Court orders a recount of the Bundestag election.”

Sahra Wagenknecht, founder of the BSW and a complainant in the case before the Constitutional Court

If the court refuses a recount, the party is considering a complaint to the European Court of Human Rights.

Background and possible outcomes

The court has already turned down earlier BSW challenges. In May 2025 it rejected organ disputes in which the party demanded a review of the close result. The party's only comparable success came in December 2023, when the court ordered a partial repeat of the Bundestag election in Berlin after a public hearing, with voting held again in 455 of the 2,256 polling districts. If the court orders a recount, the Federal Returning Officer would have to organise it, and it could possibly take place in only some polling stations. Handelsblatt describes a loss in Karlsruhe as another heavy setback for a party founded in 2024. Its poll ratings have fallen, and it lost two of the three state elections this autumn. It cleared the five percent hurdle only in Saxony-Anhalt, where its parliamentary cooperation with the AfD is causing a dispute within the party.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Organizations
Bundestag

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar