Safety · Brooklyn and New York City
Brooklyn building collapse kills eight as nearby excavation faces scrutiny
A three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue fell onto an adjacent construction lot on 11 November, killing eight people and injuring at least 18. An analysis by The New York Times points to excavation next door as the likely cause.
AI text based on reports by EL MUNDO, Super Express, EL PAÍS and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
A New York Times analysis based on videos, a 3-D model and planning documents says excavation at the neighboring site most likely weakened the foundation of the 96-year-old building.
Brooklyn prosecutors are examining whether the work on the neighboring plot broke the law. Officials approved deep excavation in March, later ordered work halted, and imposed a $10,000 fine after work continued.
The collapse killed six adults and two children, and at least 18 people were injured, including three firefighters and three construction workers.
City authorities sent inspectors to 160 other construction sites, and at least five were ordered to halt work after the collapse.
- MarchOfficials approve deep excavation for a new project next door, and work is later ordered halted
- 11 NovThree-story building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue collapses onto an adjacent construction lot
- After the collapseInspectors sent to 160 other construction sites, with at least five ordered to halt work
What happened on Flatbush Avenue
On 11 November, in the afternoon, a three-story residential building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn collapsed within seconds. The 96-year-old structure fell onto an adjacent lot where construction work was under way, and its collapse buried residents and workers who were nearby. Eight people died, six adults and two children, and at least 18 people were injured, including three firefighters and three construction workers. The building tilted, split diagonally across the middle and crumbled in on itself, and the collapse tore part of the wall off the neighboring building. A camera on a passing MTA bus captured the moment, and the footage was released by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
- Killed
- 8
- Injured (at least)
- 18
Data from the article text
Excavation next door under scrutiny
An analysis by The New York Times, drawing on videos, a 3-D reconstruction of the site and planning documents reviewed by structural and geotechnical engineers, concludes the building most likely fell because excavation next door weakened its century-old foundation. The plans for the construction site were incomplete and gave insufficient support to the foundation of the three-story building. Carrying out those plans removed even more of that support, according to the experts the Times consulted. Jane Raba, director of structural engineering at RA Engineering in New York, said the planning documents showed a disregard for engineering standards and confirmed the broad findings of the investigation.
Raba put the risk in stark terms when she described the project.
“Even if they had followed the plans precisely, the building would have been in danger of collapsing.”
She added that the poor execution of the plans pushed the project far beyond that threshold of danger. The Times video analysis found that the wall beside the excavation dropped about 18 inches before breaking apart. Dan Eschenasy, a former chief structural engineer at the New York City Buildings Department, said the first movement of that wall pointed to something giving way at foundation level, based on a CCTV video filmed from a deli across the street.
Permits, stop orders and a fine
Brooklyn prosecutors are examining whether the work on the neighboring plot broke the law, according to a New York Post report. In March, before the collapse, officials approved deep excavation for a new project on that site, and the work was later ordered halted. Part of the work continued despite the ban, and a fine of $10,000 was imposed. Building documents also recorded cracks in the walls of the collapsed building before it fell. Experts suggested the excavation may have lacked adequate safeguards for the building beside it.
Inspections and the wider neighborhood
After the collapse, city authorities sent inspectors to 160 other construction sites, and in at least five cases they ordered work halted. The damaged building beside the site is also to be demolished because it risks falling, city officials said. The cause of the collapse remains under investigation.
In the Flatbush neighborhood, residents have complained for years about cracked walls, missing smoke detectors, leaks and damp. Families of the victims are now calling for justice, and local residents have taken to the streets against property owners and what they describe as neglect in the community.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- EL MUNDOA camera captures the moment a building collapses in New York killing 8 peopleUna cámara capta el momento en el que un edificio se derrumba en Nueva York matando a 8 personas · original in Spanish
- Super ExpressBuilding full of people collapsed in New York! New video is terrifyingBudynek pełen ludzi zawalił się w Nowym Jorku! Nowy film przeraża · original in Polish
- EL PAÍSThe collapse of building 1321, the tragedy that uncovered New York's cracks in a weekEl derrumbe del edificio 1321, la tragedia que destapó en una semana las grietas de Nueva York | Reportaje · original in Spanish
- The New York TimesExcavation Compromised Building That Collapsed, Visual Evidence Suggests
- Places
- Brooklyn, New York City
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar