Football · Cardiff and Madrid
Portugal doctor defends dropping Bernardo Silva over functional thigh injury
The Portuguese Football Federation's clinical director said on 16 November that Bernardo Silva's thigh problem was functional and that playing on would have risked a full tear. Real Madrid's scans found no structural injury.
AI text based on reports by TSF Rádio Notícias, SAPO, SIC Notícias and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Bernardo Silva reported pain at the back of his thigh after the match against Denmark on 14 November, and the federation judged him unfit to face Wales.
Clinical director José Carlos Noronha called the problem a functional injury and said structural ones can keep players out for three to six weeks or more.
Real Madrid said an MRI scan in Madrid found no injury and that the midfielder is fully fit to train and play.
Portugal lead Group A4 with 12 points, three more than Denmark, and need one point against Wales on Tuesday, 17 November, to finish first.
Bernardo Silva leaves the Portugal camp
Bernardo Silva left the Portugal squad before the Nations League match in Cardiff after reporting discomfort at the back of his thigh. The Real Madrid midfielder, who captains the national team, first complained on Saturday, 14 November, after the heavy defeat to Denmark. According to coach Jorge Jesus, the player had asked to do some sprint drills with assistant coach Pedro and Fábio Silva once the match ended. The medical department then told Jesus that the discomfort meant two days of recovery would be a risk. The federation's medical staff judged him unfit, and he returned to Real Madrid ahead of the Wales game.
The medical explanation
José Carlos Noronha, the federation's clinical director, told reporters in Cardiff that the problem was a functional injury rather than a structural one. He said the player had been examined after the match and that a localised pain was found in the back of the thigh. Noronha argued that complaints of this kind often develop into full ruptures if the player trains or plays within two or three days. He added that roughly half of such complaints show negative imaging results, and he called the decision to rule the player out correct. He also said a structural injury could keep a player sidelined for three to six weeks or longer.
“I recall that 50 per cent of these complaints are negative in terms of imaging.”
Real Madrid's scans and MRI timing
Real Madrid said Bernardo Silva had an MRI scan in Madrid and is fully fit to train and play. Noronha said no scan was carried out in Portugal after the match, because an MRI taken too early can give a false negative. The timing windows quoted in the coverage vary, from 24 to 48 hours. Noronha said the injury occurred on 14 November, so playing on 17 November would have been premature even though the Madrid scan showed no injury. Spanish press reports had earlier said the player was not seriously injured and could be available again soon.
Jorge Jesus on the decision
Jesus said at the press conference that the diagnosis was not his to make and that the medical staff had given him the assessment. He said the two days between matches left no time for the player to recover before the Wales game. He added that the medical department had told him it was a muscular discomfort. Jesus also said the squad would have kept the player with more time.
“If we had more time, Bernardo would not have left and would have stayed with the national team.”
Wales match and what comes next
Portugal are already through to the quarter-finals and need one point against Wales in Cardiff on Tuesday, 17 November, at 19:45 to finish first in Group A4. They have 12 points, three more than Denmark, while Norway have six and Wales three. Finishing first gives them seeding for the quarter-finals. Bernardo Silva wished the squad luck on Instagram before the match. Germany's Sven Jablonski referees the game. Real Madrid resumed training on Tuesday, with internationals expected to return gradually, and the player is expected to be available for the Saturday match against Celta de Vigo at the Santiago Bernabéu.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- TSF Rádio NotíciasNational team doctor explains Bernardo Silva's release: “He risked months on the sidelines”Médico da seleção explica dispensa de Bernardo Silva: "Arriscava meses de paragem" · original in Portuguese
- SAPONational team doctor clarifies Bernardo Silva's injuryMédico da Seleção Nacional esclarece lesão de Bernardo Silva · original in Portuguese
- SAPONational team doctor on Bernardo Silva's injury: “50 percent of complaints are negative in terms of imaging”Médico da seleção e a lesão de Bernardo Silva: "50 por cento das queixas são negativas em termos de imagem" · original in Portuguese
- SIC NotíciasJorge Jesus and national team doctor explain Bernardo Silva's situationJorge Jesus e médico da Seleção explicam situação de Bernardo Silva · original in Portuguese
- Bernardo Silva
- Real Madrid midfielder and Portugal captain whose thigh complaint led to his departure from the squad
- Jorge Jesus
- Portugal national team coach who commented on the player's departure at the press conference
- Organizations
- Real Madrid CF
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar