Government · Warsaw, Lublin, and Hajnówka

Military appeals court quashes acquittal of soldier who fired at Belarus border migrants

The Military Regional Court in Warsaw sent the case of private Karol S. back to the first-instance court on Friday, 20 November 2026, after prosecutors appealed his acquittal over a 2024 border shooting.

AI text based on reports by NIEZALEZNA.PL, wpolityce.pl and Rzeczpospolita. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Warsaw, Lublin, Hajnówka · Poland
How it came to this
  1. 25 MarSoldier fires 12 warning shots at a migrant group near Dubicze Cerkiewne
  2. September 2025Hajnówka District Court acquits all five accused activists
  3. March 2026On the Prosecutor General's instruction, appeals in the Hajnówka case are withdrawn
  4. 20 NovMilitary Regional Court in Warsaw quashes the soldier's acquittal and returns the case

The appeal ruling

On Friday, 20 November 2026, the Military Regional Court in Warsaw overturned the acquittal of private Karol S. and sent the case back to the first-instance court for a new hearing. The soldier had been cleared by the Military Garrison Court in Lublin of exceeding his powers and exposing other people to direct danger of loss of life or serious health damage. Prosecutors had appealed that verdict. The appellate court did not share the lower court's conclusions and held that the evidence required fresh analysis. Under the ruling, the proceedings begin again before a military garrison court, unless the defence successfully challenges the new decision.

What happened near Dubicze Cerkiewne

According to the indictment drawn up by the District Prosecutor's Office in Warsaw, the events took place on 25 March 2024 near Dubicze Cerkiewne, where a group of migrants had crossed the border from Belarus illegally. Prosecutors said the soldier moved along the border road at a distance of between about 210 and about 164 metres from the group, then took a shooting stance and fired 12 warning shots from his service weapon. Investigators said at least three bullets ricocheted after hitting coils of razor wire, a concrete pole and the ground, while the other nine passed directly beside the group. As the migrants retreated toward the Belarusian side, they threw branches and stones at Polish officers and soldiers, who responded with tear gas.

The court's reasoning

Presenting the justification of the appellate ruling, Judge Paweł Więcek, a colonel, said:

“Firing 12 warning shots, at least three of which exposed the group to direct danger to life or health, met the elements of the alleged offence.”

Paweł Więcek

Więcek also said that two Border Guard officers and two soldiers intervening at the time faced the same direct danger. At the first-instance stage, Judge Radosław Hunek had stressed that soldiers have a constitutional and statutory duty to defend the country's borders, and that the use of weapons is one of their powers, exercised in proportion to the threat.

The Hajnówka comparison

Lawyer Bartosz Lewandowski used a post on X to set the Karol S. case against proceedings concerning five people described as activists from Hajnówka. They were charged with helping migrants stay in Poland illegally. Four of them were detained while transporting foreigners who had crossed the border illegally, and the fifth was said to have taken part in helping them. In September 2025 the District Court in Hajnówka acquitted all the accused. Prosecutors had sought prison terms of one year and four months and then appealed, but in March 2026, on the instruction of Prosecutor General Waldemar Żurek, the appeals were withdrawn and the acquittal became final. Lewandowski argued it was inconsistent for prosecutors to challenge one acquittal while dropping the challenge in the other, and he tied the second decision to the personal instruction of the justice minister. The sequence of dates across both cases is shown below.

Next steps for the defence

The defence can file a complaint with the Supreme Court against the ruling that returned the case to the first-instance court. Defence lawyers told PAP after the hearing that they would consider further steps once they receive the written justification. If the complaint is not upheld, the trial will restart before the military garrison court.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Places
Warsaw, Lublin

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar