Diplomacy · Bucharest and Quanzhou

Romanian justice minister meets father of Alina Apostol, jailed in China since 2017

Justice Minister Radu Marinescu met on Wednesday, 18 November, with the father of Alina Apostol and the lawyer the family chose, at the ministry's headquarters. Apostol, sentenced in China, has still not been transferred to Romania despite a 2023 Romanian court order.

AI text based on reports by Libertatea and Stirile ProTV. Published . How it is made

For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).

In brief

Bucharest, Quanzhou · Romania, China
How it came to this
  1. 2017Apostol is held in China, where she has been imprisoned since 2017
  2. July 2019Quanzhou People's Court sentences her to 13 years and six months for bank card fraud
  3. March 2023Bucharest Court of Appeal adapts the sentence to 9 years and 4 months and orders transfer to Romania
  4. 18 NovJustice minister meets her father and the family's lawyer; transfer has not yet taken place

A meeting at the ministry

Justice Minister Radu Marinescu met on Wednesday, 18 November, with the father of Alina Apostol and the lawyer chosen by the family, at the ministry's headquarters. According to a ministry communique, the purpose was to inform the family directly about the steps Romanian authorities have taken so far and to set the next stages in the case. The ministry said all legal options available were being analysed to resolve the matter and bring Apostol back to Romania. The meeting came a day after Libertatea published new details of the case, and a few days after the newspaper had written that the Romanian state had failed the woman, who has been held in China since 2017.

Sentence and transfer order

Apostol was sentenced in July 2019 by the Quanzhou People's Court in China to 13 years and six months in prison for bank card fraud. Romanian authorities later recognised that sentence in part, treating the offence as comparable to Romanian crimes of fraudulent financial operations and unauthorised access to an IT system. In March 2023 the Bucharest Court of Appeal adapted the punishment to 9 years and 4 months and ordered her transfer to a Romanian prison under international cooperation in criminal matters. Despite that order, the authorities have not brought her to Romania.

Diplomatic and legal track

The ministry said Romania is continuing a series of videoconferences with the Chinese Ministry of Justice. The talks are meant to review the current state of the case, clear up points still under discussion and identify solutions for obtaining the final agreement of the Chinese authorities, which is needed for the transfer. Marinescu stressed the need for constant communication with the family and sustained cooperation with all institutions involved, so that every legal avenue is considered. Foreign Minister Dan Neculăescu also spoke with the family and gave assurances that the foreign ministry supports the case. He said the consular network is closely monitoring respect for her rights, her detention conditions and her health, and maintaining a constant dialogue with local authorities. He added:

“Our efforts are being carried out in coordination with the Ministry of Justice, in a framework of inter-institutional cooperation adapted to the specifics of this case.”

Dan Neculăescu, romanian Minister of Foreign Affairs

Neculăescu said the foreign ministry will intensify its diplomatic efforts on these difficult cases.

Next steps

The ministry's statement after the meeting struck a similar note of continued involvement. It said:

“The Ministry of Justice remains by the family's side in this process”

Ministry of Justice

The ministry added that it will keep working on the steps within its competence, weighing both the requirements of the legal framework and the human dimension of the situation. No date for the transfer has been announced in the sources, and the Chinese authorities' final agreement is still pending.

Ask about this text

Sources and context

Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.

Support Pollar