Elections · Berlin
AfD wins Berlin Spandau seat after phone tally error reduces parliament size to 153
A phone transmission error on election night falsely awarded Spandau constituency 1 to the CDU, but verified written records confirm AfD candidate Tommy Tabor won by 34 votes, eliminating five overhang and leveling seats.
AI text based on reports by Berliner Zeitung, N-tv, DIE WELT and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Written minutes from the September 20 election confirmed Tommy Tabor won with 5,184 votes over Bettina Meißner with 5,150 votes after an initial phone report showed Meißner leading by 80.
Spandau district returning officer Katrin Zickert and state returning officer Stephan Bröchler stated ballots were tallied correctly on election night but reported incorrectly over the phone.
The loss of the CDU constituency mandate lowers overhang seats and associated leveling mandates, cutting five seats from the incoming parliament.
- 20 SeptBerlin state election takes place
- 1 OctVote reporting discrepancy identified in Spandau constituency 1
- 2 OctElection officials confirm AfD victory and five-seat reduction
- 12 OctState election committee convenes to certify final election results
Phone reporting discrepancy alters Spandau tally
Election officials in Berlin corrected the vote tally for Spandau constituency 1 after uncovering a reporting error from the September 20 state election. Preliminary results had awarded the direct constituency seat to Christian Democratic Union candidate Bettina Meißner with an 80-vote lead over Alternative for Germany candidate Tommy Tabor. A review by election authorities established that the initial telephone report transmitted on election night did not match the written minutes recorded by the polling station electoral board. While the physical ballots had been counted accurately on election night, the oral quick report relayed incorrect figures. Spandau district returning officer Katrin Zickert and Berlin state returning officer Stephan Bröchler confirmed that the official written protocol recorded 5,184 votes for Tabor and 5,150 votes for Meißner, giving Tabor a 34-vote victory. Bröchler noted that the root cause of the phone transmission error remained under review.
“Why that happened, I cannot say at the moment.”
- Tommy Tabor (AfD)
- 5184 votes
- Bettina Meißner (CDU)
- 5150 votes
Data from the article text
Mandate recalculation shrinks the Berlin Abgeordnetenhaus
The reversal of the direct seat in Spandau shifts the distribution of seats across the entire Berlin Abgeordnetenhaus. Under the preliminary election tally, the state parliament comprised 158 seats, a total that included seven overhang seats and 21 compensatory leveling seats designed to maintain proportional representation based on party second votes. The loss of the direct mandate reduces the CDU's overhang seat allocation, which in turn reduces the number of leveling seats allocated to other parties across the chamber. Bröchler confirmed that the total size of the incoming parliament drops from 158 seats to 153 seats, eliminating five legislative posts that candidates had provisionally expected to hold. Officials noted that the exact identity of the five affected lawmakers required recalculation across party lists, with determinations expected during Friday. Bröchler explained how the reduction affects incoming lawmakers across party lines.
“This would mean that the number of members of the House of Representatives is reduced compared to the preliminary election result, and candidates provisionally assumed to have been elected do not enter the House of Representatives.”
Lawmaker status and official certification timeline
The corrected vote count produces distinct outcomes for the two direct contenders in Spandau. Tabor had already secured entry to the Abgeordnetenhaus regardless of the district result because of his placement on the AfD state candidate list. Meißner's parliamentary future remains undetermined, as she occupied third place on the CDU district list and depends on the final list distribution. The Spandau district election committee convened on Friday to verify the district count, while final seat distributions across all parties depend on every district committee completing its official count. The state election committee is scheduled to meet on October 12 to formally certify the final statewide results and finalize the 153-seat composition of the state legislature.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Berliner ZeitungBerliner Wahlergebnis korrigiert: AfD gewinnt Direktmandat in Spandau
- N-tvAbgeordnetenhaus schrumpft: AfD gewinnt nach Neuauszählung Mandat in Berlin-Spandau
- DIE WELTWahlpanne in Berlin - Direktmandat geht an AfD statt an CDU, Abgeordnetenhaus wird kleiner
- Der TagesspiegelFolgen für die Zusammensetzung des Abgeordnetenhauses?: Neuauszählung ergibt anderen Wahlkreissieger in Spandau
- Tommy Tabor
- AfD candidate who won Spandau constituency 1
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar