Government · Essen
AfD chocolate Saint Nicholas with party book draws rebuke from Essen bishop
The AfD sold chocolate Saint Nicholas figures for 1.35 euros each in its online shop. Essen Bishop Franz-Josef Overbeck says the party is using Christian symbols for advertising.
AI text based on reports by Der Tagesspiegel, Handelsblatt, stern.de and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The AfD sold its chocolate Saint Nicholas figures for 1.35 euros each in its webshop, with the figure holding a book bearing the AfD logo instead of a Bible.
Essen Bishop Franz-Josef Overbeck, 62, told Bild that the party is appropriating Christian symbols and that religious symbols must never be used for party-political purposes.
An AfD spokesperson told Bild the party is liberal-conservative and committed to Christian values, so the classic Saint Nicholas suits it.
Berlin trademark lawyer Jan Froehlich called the use of a saint and the Bible as a Christian symbol legally contestable, while Blick reported it is unclear whether the party breaks the law.
The figure and its sale
The AfD offered chocolate Saint Nicholas figures for 1.35 euros each in its webshop. The figure wears a bishop's vestments, with a mitre and crozier, and holds a book with the AfD logo where a Bible would traditionally be. Bild reported that the figure can be preordered.
Bishop's criticism
Essen Bishop Franz-Josef Overbeck, 62, told the Bild newspaper that the party is appropriating Christian symbols for its advertising.
“The AfD is appropriating Christian symbols for party advertising.”
Overbeck called the depiction a transgression. He said a Saint Nicholas in a blue cloak with mitre, staff and a Gospel bearing the AfD logo simply does not work. He acknowledged that football clubs also sell chocolate Santa figures in club colours, but said they usually leave out Christian symbols. He called for a consensus that religious symbols of this kind are never used for party-political purposes.
Party response
An AfD spokesperson told Bild that the party is liberal-conservative and clearly committed to Christian values, so the classic form of Saint Nicholas suits it well. According to Bild, the spokesperson said the figure serves as a reminder of a saint who embodied Christian values like few others. Blick reported that the party defends the product as fitting its values, and that it is unclear whether the action breaches any law.
Legal doubts and church background
Berlin trademark lawyer Jan Froehlich told Bild that using a saint and the Bible as a Christian symbol in this way is legally contestable. He argued that linking a revered figure to messages that can be seen as politically extremist could make the use immoral under trademark law. Nicholas of Myra, born in the 3rd century, is a symbol of mercy and generosity. The Protestant and Catholic churches have distanced themselves from the AfD several times, accusing it of positions that demean people. In spring 2024 the German Bishops' Conference unanimously adopted a statement that völkisch nationalism and Christianity are incompatible, calling right-wing extremism the most pressing danger to the liberal order.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Der TagesspiegelInstead of a Bible a party book under the arm: Bishop criticizes AfD chocolate Saint NicholasStatt Bibel ein Parteibuch unter dem Arm: Bischof kritisiert AfD-Schoko-Nikolaus - "geht so nicht · original in German
- HandelsblattChocolate Saint Nicholas: Bishop Overbeck accuses the AfD of a transgressionSchoko-Nikolaus: Bischof Overbeck wirft der AfD Grenzüberschreitung vor · original in German
- stern.deAfD chocolate Saint NicholasAfD-Schoko-Nikolaus - Bischof kritisiert Grenzüberschreitung · original in German
- RP OnlineBishop Overbeck against blue AfD chocolate Saint Nicholas: “Never use religious symbols of this kind for party-political purposes”Bischof Overbeck gegen blauen AfD-Schoko-Nikolaus: "Religiöse Symbole dieser Art niemals für parteipolitische Zwecke nutzen · original in German
- Franz-Josef Overbeck
- Catholic Bishop of Essen who criticised the AfD's chocolate Saint Nicholas figure as a transgression
- Jan Froehlich
- Berlin trademark lawyer who called the use of a saint and the Bible as a Christian symbol legally contestable
- Places
- Essen
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar