Government · London
Britain drops plan to scrap jury trials for sentences under three years
Prime Minister Andy Burnham and Justice Secretary Alex Norris have reversed plans to introduce judge-only trials in Crown Courts, retaining juries for defendants facing prison terms of up to three years while maintaining juryless hearings for complex fraud.
AI text based on reports by The Telegraph, Reuters, Financial Times News and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Justice Secretary Alex Norris confirmed the government dropped plans to eliminate jury trials for cases with sentences under three years.
The Ministry of Justice will still permit single judges without juries to hear complex financial crime and fraud proceedings.
Magistrates will gain powers to issue sentences of up to two years, up from one year, and will decide the venue for either-way offences.
- July 2026Andy Burnham succeeds Keir Starmer as prime minister.
- September 2026Andy Burnham restricts the prisoner early release scheme following an urgent review.
- 4 OctJustice Secretary Alex Norris announces the reversal of plans to scrap jury trials.
Policy reversal on Crown Court trials
The British government has abandoned plans to remove the right to trial by jury for defendants facing prison sentences of under three years in England and Wales. Justice Secretary Alex Norris announced that ministers would discard the proposals initially introduced under former prime minister Sir Keir Starmer and former justice secretary David Lammy. The earlier reform, based on a review by retired judge Sir Brian Leveson, had sought to create a juryless tier in the Crown Court where judges sitting alone would rule on less serious crimes. Norris stated that the administration changed course after receiving severe criticism from lawyers and backbench Labour members of parliament. Ministers will, however, proceed with plans allowing complex fraud and financial cases to be heard by a judge alone.
“I have heard the strength of feeling on the proposals for increasing the number of judge-alone trials in the Crown Court and have made the decision to change course.”
Backlog pressures and alternative reforms
The scrapped proposals had been designed to reduce substantial delays across the justice system. The backlog of cases awaiting jury trial in Crown Courts reached nearly 81,000 at the end of June 2026, almost doubling since 2020 and threatening to reach 100,000 without intervention. Instead of establishing a judge-only Crown Court bench, the Ministry of Justice will double magistrates' maximum sentencing powers from one year to two years of imprisonment. In addition, defendants charged with "either-way" offences, such as theft, will lose the right to elect a Crown Court jury trial, leaving the choice of venue to magistrates. The government will also introduce artificial intelligence tools and virtual hearings to accelerate court administration.
- Current limit
- 1 years
- Proposed limit
- 2 years
Data from the article text
Legal and political reactions
Legal organizations broadly welcomed the preservation of jury trials while expressing reservations about the alternative measures. Andrew Thomas, chair of the Criminal Bar Association, thanked ministers for changing course but stated that a severe threat to jury trials remains. Bar Council chair Kirsty Brimelow warned that increasing magistrates' powers could prove counterproductive while magistrates' courts manage their own rising case backlogs. Critics, including Doughty Street Chambers founder Geoffrey Robertson, had argued that cutting jury access dismantled vital constitutional protections without fixing long-term court underfunding. Meanwhile, the victims' commissioner expressed concern that abandoning the Leveson recommendations could leave victims waiting longer for verdicts.
Adjustments to inherited justice policies
The retreat on jury trials represents the latest modification of inherited justice policies under Andy Burnham, who became prime minister in July 2026. In September 2026, Burnham restricted an emergency prisoner early release program that had been enacted to ease prison overcrowding, altering the criteria after an urgent review. That intervention prevented the early release of two individuals convicted in the killing of police officer Andrew Harper. Norris argued that dropping the structural requirement for judge-only courts will allow the government to enact efficiency measures sooner. Shadow justice secretary Nick Timothy attributed the policy shift to parliamentary opposition pressure, while ministers insisted the revised approach will target backlogs more quickly.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Alex Norris
- Justice Secretary of the United Kingdom who announced the policy reversal
- Andy Burnham
- Prime Minister of the United Kingdom who took office in July 2026
- Keir Starmer
- Former Prime Minister of the United Kingdom whose court policies were dropped
- David Lammy
- Former Justice Secretary who previously proposed reducing jury trials
- Andrew Thomas
- Chair of the Criminal Bar Association
- Kirsty Brimelow
- Chair of the Bar Council
- Brian Leveson
- Retired senior judge who recommended curbs on jury trials in a court review
- Geoffrey Robertson
- Founder of Doughty Street Chambers and critic of the original proposals
- Nick Timothy
- Shadow Justice Secretary
- Places
- London, United Kingdom, England, Wales, Great Britain
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar