Government · Lisbon
Portuguese parliament rejects loss of nationality penalty as PSD and Chega fail to agree
All three attempts to make loss of Portuguese nationality a possible punishment for serious crimes were voted down in parliament on 3 July 2026, after the two main right-wing parties failed to bridge their differences over the unconstitutional decree.
AI text based on reports by Notícias ao Minuto, Observador, SAPO and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
Chega's confirmation attempt failed 56-152, and PSD/CDS amendments were also voted down, with Chega joining the left against them.
The original decree had been vetoed by former president Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa and twice ruled unconstitutional by the Constitutional Court, the last time unanimously in May 2026.
PSD accused Chega of voting with the left, while Chega accused PSD of softening the proposal and breaking their earlier agreement.
Minister Leitão Amaro said the loss of nationality was justified for crimes that break civic bonds, though he conceded it would be applied rarely.
PS, BE and others said PSD and CDS were legislating to mimic Chega's far-right rhetoric and that the decree would create two classes of citizens.
Parliament rejected both the original decree on loss of nationality and a softened version proposed by the PSD and CDS, leaving the government's plan to introduce an accessory penalty dead. The votes ended months of legislative back-and-forth that included two unanimous rulings of unconstitutionality from the Constitutional Court and a veto by former president Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa.
What was voted on
Chega, led by André Ventura, forced a confirmation vote on the original decree, hoping to override the Constitutional Court with a two-thirds majority. Only 56 deputies from Chega and CDS supported it, while 152 from PSD, PS, Iniciativa Liberal, Livre, PCP, Bloco de Esquerda, PAN and JPP voted against. PSD then put forward amendments with CDS that narrowed the scope of crimes to terrorism, attacks against the state, qualified homicide, rape and criminal association, but those changes were also defeated: PSD and CDS backed them, Iniciativa Liberal abstained, and all other parties, including Chega, voted no.
The rift on the right
PSD vice-president Alexandre Poço accused Chega of causing the failure.
“Today, the whole country will know that whoever acquires nationality and later commits a terrorism crime cannot lose their nationality. And whose responsibility? Chega's, a party that seeks to benefit from chaos.”
Chega deputy Vanessa Barata shot back that PSD had gone back on their earlier deal.
“The Portuguese deserve to know the truth. And the truth is that today the PSD wanted to change the decree, make it softer, flimsier, cuddlier and more to the liking of the left. You lacked courage.”
The government's defence
Minister of the Presidency António Leitão Amaro argued that committing extremely serious crimes that break civic bonds must carry the possibility of losing nationality. He called the penalty "reasonable, necessary" and stressed that it was of "rare application" and met the Constitutional Court's concerns.
“We cannot have the State with hands tied in limit situations.”
Left-wing criticism
Left-wing deputies used the debate to accuse PSD and CDS of pandering to Chega's far-right narrative. PS deputy and constitutionalist Isabel Moreira called the decree "a gigantic concession to the far-right" that created first- and second-class nationals.
“The right's objective was never to legislate well, it was to produce a newspaper headline. When you legislate for headlines, you end up legislating against the Constitution.”
PS deputy Luís Testa asked PSD what partners it would now choose for constitutional revision, while Iniciativa Liberal, which had abstained on the PSD/CDS proposal, saw its former president Rui Rocha vote in favour.
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Notícias ao MinutoPSD e Chega trocam acusações após chumbo da perda da nacionalidade
- ObservadorPerda da nacionalidade cai. PSD e Chega não se entenderam e propostas acabaram chumbadas
- SAPOParlamento chumba perda da nacionalidade para quem comete crimes
- Notícias ao MinutoAmpla maioria chumba perda da nacionalidade defendida pelo Chega
- André Ventura
- Chega party leader
- Alexandre Poço
- PSD parliamentary vice-president
- Vanessa Barata
- Chega deputy
- António Leitão Amaro
- Minister of the Presidency
- Isabel Moreira
- PS deputy and constitutional law scholar
- Marcelo Rebelo de Sousa
- former President of Portugal, vetoed the decree
- Rui Rocha
- former president of Iniciativa Liberal
- Luís Testa
- PS deputy
- Fabian Figueiredo
- Bloco de Esquerda deputy
- Places
- Lisbon
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar