Spain's Former Interior Minister Denies Role in 'Kitchen' Spy Operation, Contradicts Deputy's Testimony
Jorge Fernández Díaz, Spain's former interior minister, told a Madrid court he learned of the 'Operation Kitchen' spy scandal through the media, directly contradicting his former deputy who claims he briefed the minister on the operation.
The 'Operation Kitchen' Trial
Spain's former Interior Minister Jorge Fernández Díaz took the stand at the National Court in Madrid on Thursday, denying any knowledge or involvement in the 'Operation Kitchen', a controversial parapolitical spy operation allegedly orchestrated to steal or destroy documents from Luis Bárcenas, the former treasurer of the ruling Partido Popular (PP). The prosecution is seeking a 15-year prison sentence for Fernández Díaz.
I didn't know anything until it began to appear in the media. Not from above, not from below. Not from the right, not from the left.
The operation, allegedly paid for with reserved public funds, reportedly aimed to recover sensitive information about the PP's secret ledger, the so-called 'Bárcenas papers', which detailed a system of under-the-table bonus payments to party officials. Bárcenas threatened to hand the documents over to the judge in the Gürtel corruption case.
Contradicting Testimonies
Fernández Díaz's statement directly contradicts the account of his former number two, former State Secretary of Security Francisco Martínez, who testified just before him. Martínez claimed the ex-minister had consulted him in July 2013 about the recruitment of Bárcenas's driver, Sergio Ríos, as a police informant. Martínez said he confirmed the driver's status with the Deputy Operational Director, Eugenio Pino, and informed Fernández Díaz. Fernández Díaz denied this entire exchange, stating, "I asked Eugenio Pino, but he didn't answer me immediately. Later, he confirmed it and I told the minister, who never told me how he found out."
Martínez himself presented a defensive strategy, answering only questions from his own lawyer and the court. He denied ordering any spying on the Bárcenas family, calling the suppresssed alleged search for Bárcenas's hard drives a "media legend" and a "fantasy".
That stuff about Bárcenas' hard drives is a media legend that has had a long run. That someone ordered a search for hard drives is not only false; it's a fantasy.
A Trial of Competing Narratives
While Martínez has been instrumental in incriminating Fernández Díaz through the submission of SMS messages to a notary, his testimony avoided any direct questioning about the specific messages that implicate his former boss. Notably, his lawyer did not ask a single question about four crucial messages that reportedly prompted the prosecution to place the former minister in the dock. Martínez merely confirmed he received information about the driver in July 2013, without specifying that the communication was via a message he later used as evidence.
Fernández Díaz maintained that he had no personal stake in the 'Bárcenas papers' because his name did not appear in them. "Personally, it could not interest or worry me at all," he stated. He insisted that no one from the PP ever expressed concern to him regarding the leak of the party's illicit accounting.
Political Context and Media Commentary
Remarkably, on the same day as his appearance at the National Court, Fernández Díaz published an opinion column in the newspaper La Razón. In the article, he commented on what he called the "unprecedented situation" of the 'Leire case', criticizing judicial orders that saw the Guardia Civil's Central Operative Unit search the Guardia Civil's own headquarters and the PSOE's headquarters.
Seeing the UCO, the Central Operative Unit of the Civil Guard, entering, by court order, the headquarters of the Directorate-General of the Civil Guard itself as part of the investigation it is carrying out in the so-called Leire case, is absolutely unheard of.
He contrasted the current political climate under Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez with the 2018 motion of no confidence that ousted the PP government over corruption. Fernández Díaz, who faces up to 15 years for his alleged role, including on charges of embezzlement and cover-up, continues to claim the 'Kitchen' narrative is an invention, even as multiple defendants and prosecutors paint a very different picture of a 'patriotic police' unit.
- Francisco Martínez allegedly informed by Fernández Díaz about the recruitment of Bárcenas's driver, Sergio Ríos.
- First SMS message linked to Kitchen is sent, marking the initial trace of the operation in the judicial case.
- PP government ousted by a motion of no confidence heavily driven by corruption scandals, including the unfolding Kitchen case.
- Ex-Minister Jorge Fernández Díaz and ex-Secretary Francisco Martínez testify at the National Court; both deny core allegations.
Financial and Judicial Stakes
Both Fernández Díaz and Martínez face a prosecution request of 15 years in prison for their alleged involvement. Martínez revealed that he met with the controversial commissioner José Manuel Villarejo at the minister's direct instruction, acknowledging that Villarejo handled "good sources" and had conducted intelligence work for every government since 1992. Martínez admitted to sometimes feeling "stunned" by Villarejo's loquacity and claimed he now does not understand the content of some recorded conversations in the case file.
The case centers on the alleged use of reserved public funds to run a parallel police operation targeting Bárcenas, who was found to have accounts in Switzerland managed by Arturo Fasana. Martínez defended the Ministry's interest as a legitimate effort to locate additional funds, rather than a cover-up of the PP's illegal financing.
