Safety · Braunschweig and Haltern am See
German court dismisses victims' relatives lawsuit over 2015 Germanwings crash
The Braunschweig Regional Court has dismissed a civil damages lawsuit filed by 30 relatives of Germanwings Flight 9525 victims against the Federal Republic of Germany, ruling that state liability is secondary to airline claims.
AI text based on reports by ZEIT ONLINE, N-tv, Frankfurter Allgemeine and other publishers. Changed . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The Landgericht Braunschweig dismissed claims from 30 relatives seeking up to 110,000 euros each from the Federal Republic of Germany.
The court ruled that official state liability is excluded because primary claims under the Montreal Convention must be directed against Germanwings GmbH.
Lawyer Julius Reiter argued that the Luftfahrt-Bundesamt failed to properly monitor the medical fitness of co-pilot Andreas Lubitz prior to the 24 March 2015 disaster.
- 24 MarGermanwings Flight 9525 crashes in the French Alps, killing all 150 people on board
- May 2026The Braunschweig Regional Court issues preliminary guidance indicating little chance of success
- August 2026Oral hearings conclude before the Braunschweig Regional Court
- 6 OctThe court formally dismisses the damages lawsuit against the Federal Republic of Germany
Civil claim dismissed in Braunschweig
The Landgericht Braunschweig dismissed a civil compensation lawsuit on Tuesday brought by 30 relatives of the victims of the 2015 Germanwings disaster. The claimants had sought up to 110,000 euros each from the Federal Republic of Germany under state liability provisions. The court determined that claims against the federal government do not apply because primary and equivalent claims exist against the airline, Germanwings GmbH. The presiding judge referred to the Montreal Convention, which governs liability in international commercial aviation and allows injured parties to assert compensation claims directly against carriers. Because the Federal Aviation Office (Luftfahrt-Bundesamt, or LBA) is based in Braunschweig, Lower Saxony, the regional court held jurisdiction over the civil proceedings against the German state.
Scrutiny of aeromedical oversight
The legal action focused on whether German civil aviation regulators properly monitored the fitness of pilots before the disaster. The claimants argued that the state failed in its regulatory duty because medical assessments in 2013 and 2014 did not adequately identify severe psychiatric risks. Co-pilot Andreas Lubitz had previously spent time in a psychiatric clinic two weeks before the crash, was on certified medical leave, and had medications in his blood on the day of the flight. Previous court cases in Frankfurt am Main and Hamm had addressed aspects of medical oversight, leading the relatives to pursue the federal authority. Attorney Julius Reiter, representing the families, stated that the action aimed to clarify administrative responsibility rather than secure monetary payments.
“Compensation is not clarification. It is not primarily about more money, but about the unresolved question of whether state safety and supervisory structures failed, and what consequences must be drawn from that for aviation safety.”
Background of the crash
On 24 March 2015, Germanwings Flight 4U 9525 was en route from Barcelona to Düsseldorf when Lubitz locked the captain out of the cockpit. The 27-year-old co-pilot deliberately initiated a high-speed descent into a mountain ridge in the French Alps, destroying the Airbus aircraft. All 150 people on board lost their lives, comprising 144 passengers and 6 crew members, mostly from Germany and Spain. Among the passengers were 16 high school students and 2 teachers from a gymnasium in Haltern am See returning from an exchange program. French public prosecutor Brice Robin described the co-pilot as suffering from acute psychosis on the day of the crash.
Safety regulation scrutiny
The ruling followed earlier indications from the court in May and during oral hearings in August, when the judge notified the plaintiffs that their claim faced statutory hurdles. The relatives expressed disappointment that the court did not evaluate expert evidence on aviation medical standards or state supervisory practices. Reiter argued that Germany defines the legal criteria under which commercial pilots fly and must guarantee that European safety requirements are enforced. The claimants maintained that judicial review is necessary to determine whether regulatory intervention could have prevented the tragedy.
“It is about something much more fundamental: should the state have acted differently based on the risks known to it and the existing European safety standards, and could the disaster possibly have been prevented as a result? These questions deserve a judicial review.”
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- ZEIT ONLINELandgericht Braunschweig: Germanwings-Katastrophe: Angehörige scheitern mit Klage
- N-tvPingpong um Schuldfrage: Gericht urteilt an Hinterbliebenen von 149 Todesopfern vorbei
- Frankfurter AllgemeineSchmerzensgeld nach Germanwings-Absturz: Gericht weist Klage von Hinterbliebenen ab
- Neue Zürcher ZeitungGermanwings-Prozess: Gericht weist Klage Hinterbliebener ab
- Andreas Lubitz
- Germanwings co-pilot who intentionally crashed Flight 9525 in 2015
- Places
- Germany, Brunswick, Barcelona, Düsseldorf, Spain
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar