Housing · Berlin
German coalition moves to ban state-level expropriation of housing giants, Berlin SPD and Left cry foul
The CDU/CSU-SPD government wants to outlaw state-level takeovers of large landlords, a direct response to Berlin's 2021 referendum. Critics call it a gift to the Left ahead of September's city election.
AI text based on reports by Der Tagesspiegel, DIE WELT, Frankfurter Allgemeine and other publishers. Published . How it is made
For membersThe first 30 seconds for everyone. Synthetic voice (AI).
In brief
The CDU/CSU-SPD coalition will pass a law prohibiting states from expropriating large landlords' rental portfolios, citing investor uncertainty.
Several Berlin SPD MPs oppose the move, arguing it undermines local democracy and hands the Left a campaign issue ahead of the 20 September state election.
Left leaders Heidi Reichinnek and Elif Eralp condemned the ban as a gift to property sharks and pledged to continue pushing for socialisation.
Only 206,600 homes were finished in 2025, far below the estimated need of at least 100,000 more per year; construction costs have jumped over 50% since 2020.
- 1 SeptBerlin initiative 'Deutsche Wohnen & Co enteignen' submits draft law for socialisation of large housing companies.
- 3 JulFederal coalition agrees to ban state-level expropriation of private rental portfolios.
- 20 SeptBerlin state election; Left party leads polls, making expropriation a central campaign issue.
The federal intervention
Germany's ruling coalition has agreed to pass a federal law that would prevent individual states from expropriating the rental portfolios of large housing companies. The decision, announced after a coalition committee meeting, is framed as a measure to restore investor confidence and boost new construction. Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU) said the debate over expropriation had caused international concern. "In der ganzen Welt wird gefragt: Was ist da in Deutschland los?" he told reporters, adding that when state-level decisions create nationwide problems, the federal government must act.
“When decisions at the state level lead to problems for all of Germany, we react.”
Berlin's 2021 vote and the new push
In 2021, a majority of Berlin voters backed a non-binding referendum to socialise the housing stock of companies with more than 3,000 units. The initiative "Deutsche Wohnen & Co enteignen" submitted a draft law last September, preparing a new popular initiative. The federal ban would pre-empt any such move. Several Berlin SPD MPs criticised the plan. Hakan Demir called it "a campaign gift to the Left" that would restrict Berlin's political room for manoeuvre. Annika Klose, the SPD parliamentary group's social policy spokesperson, noted that expropriation is anchored in the Basic Law and should remain an option for states.
“A ban at the federal level would restrict Berlin's political room for manoeuvre and, given the ongoing debates, would be a campaign gift to the Left.”
Left party vows resistance
The Left party, which has surged to first place in recent Berlin polls, reacted with fury. Parliamentary group leader Heidi Reichinnek accused the government of putting corporate profits above constitutional rights. "Vonovia frohlockt, die Aktienkurse steigen," she said, claiming the government was protecting "property sharks." Berlin's lead candidate Elif Eralp pledged to defy the ban and push ahead with socialisation, insisting the city needs more affordable housing and that the will of Berlin voters must be respected.
“The announcement is nothing less than a shocking admission that for this government, the profit interests of housing corporations rank higher than constitutionally protected rights.”
Housing shortage and construction slump
The backdrop is a deepening housing crisis. More than a million homes are missing across Germany, and completions fell to 206,600 in 2025, with a further decline expected this year. Construction costs have soared: the average cost to build one square metre of living space in a major city reached €4,630, up over 50% since 2020, excluding land prices. The coalition argues that the mere debate over expropriation has deterred investors. CSU leader Markus Söder rejected the notion that the ban is primarily aimed at stopping a Left victory in Berlin, insisting it is about ending "socialism" and reviving private construction.
Other measures and reactions
Alongside the ban, the coalition agreed to set up a federal housing company (WBG) to support social housing construction. Building Minister Verena Hubertz (SPD) welcomed the clarity, saying the focus should be on investment, new builds, and strong tenant protections. CDU construction spokesperson Jan-Marco Luczak called the expropriation debate a "death blow" for private housing and urged Berlin's parties to end their "populist rent election campaign." Real estate expert Michael Voigtländer of the IW Köln warned that nationalisation without market-rate compensation would have triggered capital flight.
“We are creating clarity through federal law and focusing on what really helps people in tight housing markets: investment, new construction, and strong tenant protection in existing stock.”
Ask about this text
Sources and context
- Der TagesspiegelKoalitionsausschuss: "Wahlgeschenk an die Linke": SPD-Kritik an Enteignungsverbot
- DIE WELTBerlin: "Regierung stellt sich schützend vor Miethaie" - Linke will sich Enteignungs-Verbot widersetzen
- Frankfurter AllgemeineWohnungsbau in Deutschland: Bauen statt Enteignen - aber wer soll es machen?
- Süddeutsche ZeitungKoalition will Enteignungen von Mietbeständen verbieten. Geht das?
- Hakan Demir
- Berlin SPD Bundestag member criticising the federal expropriation ban
- Annika Klose
- SPD parliamentary group social policy spokesperson, defending states' right to expropriate
- Heidi Reichinnek
- Left party parliamentary group leader, condemning the ban as pro-corporate
- Elif Eralp
- Left party lead candidate for Berlin, vowing to defy the ban
- Markus Söder
- CSU leader, denying the ban is aimed at stopping a Left win in Berlin
- Friedrich Merz
- German Chancellor (CDU), justifying federal intervention to protect investment
- Verena Hubertz
- Federal Building Minister (SPD), welcoming the legal clarity
- Jan-Marco Luczak
- CDU/CSU construction policy spokesperson, calling expropriation a 'death blow' to private building
- Michael Voigtländer
- Real estate expert at IW Köln, warning against uncompensated nationalisation
- Places
- Berlin
Pollar is free and carries no ads in the text. Its members keep it going.
Support Pollar